Oatmeal Farm Network

A Trip to Pirate's Cove

By McFleshman’s Brewing Company

"Was this Pirate's Cove?" is a question we get a lot in the taproom. Sadly, no. The once famous bar in downtown Appleton "Pirate's Cove" had a footprint in our current Beer Garden and shared a fire escape with our building. But our building, which was built in 1916 for the Valley Dairy Co, was just the friendly neighbor to the local hot spot of the 1980s and 90s. Unfortunately, (according to legend) Pirate's Cove burned down and left many of its patrons without a local watering hole. The former owner of Pirate's Cove has come into our taproom a few times and shared stories. What a place it must have been! Many Appletonians also shared their stories, which mostly involve imbibing a… Read the full post on mcfleshmans.com