Crazy Susan's Cookies
- Type: Artisan Food Producer
- Category: Bakery
- Location: Ocean City, New Jersey
Bakery in Ocean City, NJ.
Products (54)
- 12 cookies - $42: Have a sweet helping of your favorite flavors! Please note, the box pictured is based on availability. We reserve the right to swap the box style for your order. Must have a minimum of 2 for each…
- Almond Joy: Take Chocolate Chip, mix it with almonds and coconut. Then roll it in more almonds and coconut! Top it off with a Mounds® bar! Boom. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Butterfingers: What would happen if you took a chocolate chip cookie, dipped it in Belgian milk chocolate, and topped it with chopped Butterfinger®? You’d get this crispy, peanut buttery sensation. Listed on…
- Butterscotch: We packed buttery-sweet-scotchyness in to this little treat. For morsels that are off the beaten path of chocolate chip, try this out. Don’t worry, it’s non-alcoholic. Listed on…
- Chocolate Chip: Our (semi) sweetest cookie. We load it up with chocolate chips and leave a crunchy outside with a nice, chewy center. Who can argue with a classic? Nobody, that’s who. Listed on…
- Chocolate Chip Dipped in Milk chocolate Topped with M&Ms: A chocolate chip cookie dipped in milk chocolate you say? Not good enough, we say. That’s why we added M&M’s® minis on top. All hail the chocolate! Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Chocolate Chip M&M: Our chocolate chip cookie is packed chock full of M&M’s®! Oh what a world! What a wonderful, chocolatey, candy-filled world! Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Chocolate Macaroon: Our coconutty, Belgian chocolate and cocoa macaroons might just transport you back to childhood. Or they might just put a huge smile on your face. We are happy with either. Listed on…
- Cranberry White Chocolate: One of the best thing to do with dried cranberries? Mix them with white chocolate chips, of course. The best thing to do with these cookies? Eat them, of course. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Crazy Turtle: Chocolate chips and cashews or pecans already go well together, so when we layered caramel and Belgian milk chocolate… let’s just say they’re delectable. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Double Chocolate: Chocolate chips mixed with a Belgian chocolate cookie! Double chocolate. It’s so beautiful. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Heath Bar Crunch: How can we take the traditional chocolate chip to the next level? Dip it in milk chocolate. Not enough? Okay. We added Heath Bar® crunch on top. Yummy. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Lemon Cookie: Two refreshing lemon cookies smushed together with a lemon cream cheese icing. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Little Suzy: This classic sandwich-style cookie has two chewy oatmeal cookies housing cream cheese icing. Oh. My. Word. Chewy creamy goodness. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Macaroon: Our savory-sweet macaroons are little coconut puffs baked to toasty perfection. Just pop em’ in for a great chewy, flaky treat. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Mayor’s Cookie: A fudge cookie mixed with Snicker Bar and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup® and topped with a soft creamy Rolo caramel candy. All we have to say is, “You’re welcome, Mr. Mayor.” Listed on…
- Mint Chocolate Chip: Minty. Chocolatey. Chippy. Why use after dinner mints? These are dessert and they leave your breath smelling like a cookie-baking oven. Winning. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Oatmeal Cherry Coconut: Traditional oatmeal cookie… with an upgrade! We added coconut and a cherry to give these cookies a light fruit flavor. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Oatmeal Raisin: We did it again. We took the traditional oatmeal raisin and made it better. Packed with juicy, plump raisins, this cookie will bring out your smile every time. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Oatmeal Walnut Chocolate Chip: Crazy Susan went nutty with this one. In the best way possible. We took the traditional oatmeal cookie, packed it with chocolate chips and walnuts, and then topped it with walnuts again! Super…
- Peanut Butter: It’s a creamy, savory, peanut buttery cookie. There is no chocolate needed here, the peanut butter has it covered. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Peanut Butter Dipped: Just in case you thought, “Peanut butter is good, but peanut butter and chocolate is better.” Don’t worry, we thought that too. That’s why we dipped our peanut butter cookie in Belgian milk…
- Pumpkindoodle: You thought coffee shops had the best of pumpkin? Ha. Crazy Susan has been doing this a while, she’s got it down pat – or – in this case, rolled (in cinnamon sugar). Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Reeses Peanut Butter Cup Cookie: A peanut butter cookie loaded with Reese’s Pieces® and topped with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups®. It’s a peanut butter extravaganza! Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Snickerdoodles: Snickerdoodle might have a funny name, but a cinnamon sugar cookie is no laughing matter. It’s a smiling matter, duh. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Snickers: We. Need. Nougat. Which is why we took our chocolate chip cookie, topped it with Belgian milk chocolate, and plopped a chopped Snickers® on top. Say that five times fast. Listed on…
- Sugar Cookie: All the colors of the rainbow, so pretty on a cookie, and also on the faces of children going by. Which is why we dust these sugar cookies with many, many different colors of sugar. Listed on…
- S’mores: S’more of what? This cookie, definitely. We made a graham cracker cookie, punched marshmallow fluff in the middle, and topped it with a Hershey® square. Melt with caution. Listed on…
- Macadamia White Chocolate: Some might say Susan is a bit nutty, but everyone says this cookie is nutty. A white chocolate chip cookie, loaded with chunks of Macadamia nuts. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Confetti: A basic sugar cookie packed with colorful sprinkles. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Twix: Chocolate chip cookie topped with Belgian milk chocolate and chopped Twix™ Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- White Chocolate Chip: White chocolate twist on our chocolate chip. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- York Peppermint Patty: Chocolate chip cookie topped with Belgian dark chocolate and crushed YORK Peppermint Pattie™ Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Cookies and Cream: Chocolate chip cookie topped with Belgian white chocolate and crushed Oreo. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Chocolate Chip Dark Dipped: A crunchy outside and chewy inside classic cookie dipped in dark Belgian chocolate. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Mounds: Chocolate chip cookie topped with crushed Mounds™ Bar Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Peanut Butter Fluff: Two peanut butter cookies sandwiched together with fluff and creamy peanut butter dipped in Belgian milk chocolate. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Peanut Butter Cup Patty: Peanut butter cookie topped with creamy peanut butter covered in Belgian milk chocolate topped with crushed peanut butter cups. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Chocolate Chip White Dipped: A crunchy outside and chewy inside classic cookie dipped in white Belgian chocolate. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.
- Non-Pareil Milk Chocolate Dipped: Take a chocolate chip cookie. Dip it in milk chocolate. Sprinkle on non-pareils. Faaanccccyyy. Listed on crazysusanscookies.com.