Crumbly Cafe & Bakery
- Type: Artisan Food Producer
- Category: Bakery
- Location: New York, New York
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery offers custom cakes, buttery croissants, and fresh pastries in NYC—baked in-house daily.
Products (60)
- Chocolate Covered Strawberries - $25: Elegant. Indulgent. Unforgettably Fresh. Celebrate Passover with a sweet twist on tradition! Our Chocolate-Covered Strawberries are the perfect blend of juicy, farm-fresh strawberries and rich…
- Christmas Cakepops - $39: Hand-decorated Christmas cake pops dipped in festive red, green, and winter designs. Perfect for parties, gifting, and holiday celebrations. Available for pickup or delivery. Listed at $39.00 on…
- Chocolate Mousse - $40: Celebrate Passover with a rich, elegant dessert that’s both indulgent and tradition-friendly. Our Passover Chocolate Mousse is made with premium chocolate and whipped to a silky, airy perfection.…
- Coconut Macaroons - $32.50: Passover Coconut Macaroons – Classic or Chocolate Drizzled Celebrate Passover with a timeless holiday favorite. Our Passover Coconut Macaroons are baked fresh with simple ingredients and naturally…
- Chocolate-Covered Strawberries - $25: Make Valentine’s Day unforgettable with our chocolate-covered strawberries , a timeless and romantic favorite. We hand-dip fresh, juicy strawberries in rich, velvety chocolate for the perfect…
- Flourless Chocolate Cake – Pure Indulgence Crafted in New York - $50: Passover Flourless Chocolate Cake Celebrate Passover with one of our most beloved holiday desserts. Our Flourless Chocolate Cake is rich, decadent, and naturally gluten-free , making it the perfect…
- K-Pop Cake - $154.95: Celebrate like a true star with our K-Pop Dream Cake , designed for fans who love bold, fun, and unforgettable birthday moments. This cake features a stunning galaxy-inspired purple buttercream…
- Hungry Caterpillar Cake - $174.95: Our Hungry Caterpillar Cake is a playful and charming custom cake inspired by the timeless children’s book. Designed with bright colors, whimsical details, and a fun storybook feel, this cake is…
- Chess Cake - $174.95: Chess Cake — A Luxury Statement Cake in New York The Chess Cake is not designed to blend in. It’s designed to command attention . Inspired by the timeless game of strategy and balance, this cake is…
- Golf Cake - $154.95: Celebrate in style with our Golf Birthday Cake , a timeless and elegant design inspired by the game. This cake features a smooth buttercream finish with a realistic putting green top , complete with…
- Classic Cherry Pie - $45: Tart, juicy cherries baked in a buttery golden crust — freshly baked in our NYC bakery. Serves 8–12. Pre-order now for Thanksgiving pickup or delivery! Listed at $45.00 on crumblynyc.com.
- Carousel cake - $394.95: The Carousel Cake is designed to bring nostalgia, magic, and pure joy to life — transformed into an unforgettable celebration centerpiece. This whimsical two-tier design features pastel pink, blue…
- Classic Blueberry Pie - $45: Sweet, fruity, and beautifully classic! 🫐 Our Classic Blueberry Pie features a luscious blueberry filling and a golden, flaky crust. A delicious addition to Thanksgiving dinners, holiday gatherings…
- Air Jordan Cake - $144.95: The Air Jordan Cake is designed for sneaker lovers, basketball fans, and anyone who appreciates bold design with luxury-level execution. Striking, modern, and instantly recognizable, this cake…
- The Midnight Vintage Heart Cake - $174.95: Our Midnight Vintage Heart Cake is a striking take on the classic vintage style — featuring a smooth black buttercream base paired with intricate red ribbon piping and delicate detailing. Designed…
- Wicked Cake - $174.95: Step into a world of magic, drama, and fearless color with our Wicked Cake — a striking dessert inspired by the film’s iconic aesthetic. Designed in bold green and hot pink tones , this cake…
- Baseball Cake - $154.95: The Baseball Cake is designed for true fans of the game — and for celebrations where passion, tradition, and joy take center stage. Clean, playful, and instantly recognizable, this cake captures the…
- Lavender Heart Cake - $144.95: The Lavender Heart Cake is a celebration of tenderness, elegance, and refined romance. Covered in smooth lavender buttercream and adorned with aqua piping and delicate pink rosettes , this cake…
- THE Fairytale Vintage Cake - $164.95: The Fairytale Vintage Cake is designed to feel like a moment pulled straight from a storybook. Soft, romantic, and delicately detailed, this cake blends vintage buttercream artistry with a…
- Bluey Cake 2.0 - $164.95: Bring the joy and charm of Bluey and Bingo to your next celebration with our beautifully crafted cake! Designed with a trendy, playful aesthetic, this cake features vibrant, hand-piped buttercream…
- Tini Bit Older Cake - $164.95: A little older, a lot more fabulous! 🍸 Our Tini Bit Older Cake brings a playful martini-inspired twist to birthday celebrations, with chic details, beautiful buttercream, and a personalized touch.…
- Cookie Monster Cake - $174.95: The Cookie Monster Cake is designed to deliver instant joy — with craftsmanship parents can trust. Playful, expressive, and full of personality, this cake brings a beloved cookie-loving character to…
- Decorated Christmas Cake – Red Design - $45: Our bright red Decorated Christmas Cake brings instant holiday cheer! Hand-piped with festive details and topped with the cutest little Christmas trees, it’s available in Mini (4–6) , 6” (8–10) , 9”…
- Hanukkah Decorated Chocolates - $24: Celebrate the holiday with our Hanukkah Decorated Chocolates , handcrafted in small batches and beautifully adorned with festive blue-and-white designs. Each piece is filled with rich, smooth…
- Christmas Tree Cake - $85: Bring holiday magic to your table with our Christmas Tree Cake — a whimsical, festive centerpiece baked fresh in our NYC kitchens. This tree-shaped cake features soft, moist layers, buttercream…
- Sufganiyot Jelly Donuts - $25: Celebrate the season with Crumbly’s Hanukkah jelly donuts , filled with tangy raspberry jam and finished with a light dusting of powdered sugar. These soft, airy Sufganiyot come in mini or regular…
- Helium Balloon Cake - $154.95: Our Helium Balloon Cake is one of Crumbly’s most eye-catching designs — featuring smooth buttercream and sculpted, metallic edible balloon-style numbers that create a fun floating effect. Finished…
- American Flag Cake - $195: American Flag Cake decorated with handcrafted red, white, and blue buttercream piping inspired by the U.S. flag. Perfect for Fourth of July, America 250, Memorial Day, Veterans Day, military…
- Custom Photo Sheet Cake - $245: Our Custom Photo Sheet Cake turns your favorite photo, logo, or artwork into a delicious celebration cake! 📸🎂 Finished with smooth buttercream and classic piped borders, it’s perfect for birthdays…
- Classic Buttercream Sheet Cake - $195: Our Classic Buttercream Sheet Cake is a timeless favorite for celebrations of all sizes! 🎂 Freshly baked and finished with smooth vanilla or chocolate buttercream, classic piped borders, and…
- Vintage Rectangular Engagement Cake - $475: Our Vintage Engagement Sheet Cake is a timeless beauty, featuring soft ivory buttercream, elegant vintage piping, delicate pearl accents, and a personalized message. 💍🤍 Designed in a long…
- Vintage Retirement Sheet Cake - $195: Celebrate the next chapter with our Vintage Retirement Sheet Cake! 🎉 Featuring smooth ivory buttercream, colorful vintage piping, and a personalized message, this cheerful cake is perfect for…
- Calendar Cake - $124.95: Calendar Cake – A Sweet Slice of Time! Celebrate every moment deliciously with our Calendar Cake , the trendiest way to mark your special days! Whether it’s a birthday, anniversary, or a milestone…
- Bluey Cake - $174.95: The Bluey Cake is designed to turn a child’s birthday into a joyful, unforgettable moment — while giving parents complete confidence in quality and craftsmanship. Playful, colorful, and full of…
- Bluey & Bingo Cake - $164.95: The Bluey & Bingo Cake is designed to turn a child’s birthday into a moment they’ll remember — and one parents will genuinely appreciate. Bright, cheerful, and full of personality, this cake…
- Mini Hearts Cake - $144.95: The Mini Hearts Cake is designed to express emotion in the most elegant way possible. Soft, romantic, and visually captivating, this cake turns affection into a refined centerpiece — perfect for…
- Raspberry Vintage Cake - $165.95: Raspberry Vintage Cake 🍰 Our Raspberry Vintage Cake is a timeless beauty—featuring soft, fluffy layers paired with a light raspberry filling and finished in smooth buttercream with elegant…
- Mini Bows Cake - $149.95: A soft, elegant buttercream cake adorned with delicate hand-piped mini bows for a refined and timeless look. This design brings a subtle vintage charm while staying modern and minimal—perfect for…
- Patriotic Vintage Cake - $149.95: Patriotic Vintage Cake decorated with elegant red, white, and blue vintage buttercream piping. Perfect for Fourth of July, America 250 celebrations, Memorial Day, Veterans Day, and patriotic…
- Cutie Pie Mini Cake - $45: Meet our Cutie Pie Mini Cake — a charming 4” cake designed for sharing (or not). Frosted in smooth vanilla buttercream and finished with pink swirls, festive sprinkles, and adorable conversation…
News and blog (5)
- Logo Cupcakes NYC: Branded Cupcakes, Cookies & Cakes for Corporate Events: Corporate events in New York City are rarely just about the event itself. A product launch needs to look like the brand. An office celebration should feel…
- Custom Cakes NYC: How to Find the Perfect Cake for Every Celebration: New York City knows how to celebrate. From milestone birthdays and intimate engagement parties to baby showers, corporate events and unforgettable weddings…
- How to Plan a Baby Shower or Gender Reveal in NYC: Cakes, Desserts & Party Ideas: Planning a baby shower or gender reveal in New York City should be exciting. But once you start putting the event together, the list can grow surprisingly…
- Best Kids Birthday Cakes in NYC: 5 Fun Cakes for an Unforgettable Birthday: Planning a child’s birthday party in New York City comes with plenty of decisions — the venue, decorations, guest list, entertainment and, of course, the…
- Engagement Cakes NYC: Romantic Cake Ideas for Your “Yes” Celebration: Getting engaged is one of those moments you’ll remember forever. The ring, the excitement, the first photos, the calls to family and friends — and, of course…
Menu
- Small - $50, Medium — $95, Large — $140: Mini Desserts
- Dozen - $65: Available in different flavors and quantities
- Dozen - $65: Available in different flavors and quantities
- Box of 6 - $29.50: Also available in boxes of 12 and 24
- Mini Brownies - $60: Mini Crumb Cake Platter
- Mini Bite Sized - $60
- Box of 8 - $34: Banana Pudding
- Party Size - $25.00: Dozen Mini Banana & Oreo Pudding
- Small - $11.25
- Large - $30: Nutella Cookie Pie
- Small - $13.75
- Large - $34.75: Famous Desserts
- Zip Codes - $10.00: Let's Answer Your Questions