Fat Witch Bakery
- Type: Artisan Food Producer
- Category: Bakery
- Location: New York, New York
Discover the magic behind our brownies at Fat Witch Bakery, where every batch is baked with love, using time-honored recipes and the finest ingredient!
Products (48)
- CREATE YOUR OWN BOX (18) - $60.50: Listed at $60.50 on fatwitch.com.
- CREATE YOUR OWN BOX (8) - $29.50: Listed at $29.50 on fatwitch.com.
- Fat Witch - $5.60: Born from pure chocolate passion, our original brownie casts a rich, classic spell you just can’t resist. Listed at $5.60 on fatwitch.com.
- Walnut Witch - $5.60: The Walnut Witch is rich, chocolatey, and full of nutty charm. A classic brownie with hearty walnut pieces in every bite. Listed at $5.60 on fatwitch.com.
- Snow Witch - $5.60: The Snow Witch is smooth, sweet, and full of white chocolate magic — a creamy twist on our classic that’s impossible to resist. Listed at $5.60 on fatwitch.com.
- Coffee Witch - $5.60: The Coffee Witch is a mocha-lover’s dream — deep coffee flavor, dark chocolate chips, and brownie richness in perfect harmony. Listed at $5.60 on fatwitch.com.
- Caramel Witch - $5.60: The Caramel Witch swirls buttery caramel into rich chocolate brownie for a sweet, smooth finish in every bite. Listed at $5.60 on fatwitch.com.
- Double Chocolate Witch - $5.60: Twice the chocolate, twice the charm — the Double Chocolate Witch is a bold take on our classic. Listed at $5.60 on fatwitch.com.
- Blonde Witch - $5.60: Golden, soft, and just the right amount of sweet — the Blonde Witch blends vanilla and chocolate into a treat you’ll keep reaching for. Listed at $5.60 on fatwitch.com.
- Blonde Baby - $3.50: Light, soft, and full of charm — the Blonde Baby blends vanilla richness with chunks of dark chocolate. It’s like a brownie and a chocolate chip cookie had the perfect bite-sized baby. Listed at…
- Walnut Baby - $3.50: A hearty twist on our classic brownie! With rich chocolate and bits of walnut in every bite, this little square packs bold flavor and wholesome charm — ready to enjoy in just 2–3 bites. Listed at…
- Snow Baby - $3.50: Bright, creamy, and oh-so-smooth! This white chocolate brownie with a hint of vanilla is like a sweet little snowflake you can eat anytime. Listed at $3.50 on fatwitch.com.
- Caramel Baby - $3.50: Smooth caramel meets classic brownie in every bite. Just 2-3 bites of sweet, gooey perfection that’ll keep you coming back for more. Listed at $3.50 on fatwitch.com.
- Almond Baby - $3.50: This little brownie’s got a nutty side—rich chocolate swirled with toasted almond slices and slivers for a bold, crunchy bite that’s anything but basic. Listed at $3.50 on fatwitch.com.
- Matcha Baby - $3.50: Earthy, creamy, and totally dreamy—this green tea brownie blends smooth white chocolate with mellow matcha for a soft, cake-like bite that’s pure zen with a twist. Listed at $3.50 on fatwitch.com.
- Red Baby - $3.50: A little tart, a little sweet, and a whole lot of attitude—this velvety chocolate brownie swirls in tangy cherry for a bold bite that keeps you coming back for more. Listed at $3.50 on fatwitch.com.
- Double Chocolate Baby - $3.50: Twice the chocolate, twice the fun! This brownie’s packed with rich chocolate and extra chips for a seriously delicious, can’t-stop-at-one kind of treat. Listed at $3.50 on fatwitch.com.
- Yuzu Baby - $3.50: Say hello to Yuzu Baby – a white chocolate-based brownie with a refreshing citrusy twist! Infused with the bright, tangy flavor of yuzu, this soft and delicate treat brings a perfect balance of…
- Sesame Baby - $3.50: Nutty, toasty, and totally unexpected—this brownie blends rich chocolate with crunchy toasted sesame seeds for a flavor combo that’s deliciously different. Listed at $3.50 on fatwitch.com.
- Fat Witch Logo Mug - $13: A mug that captures the spirit of New York — classic, bold, and unmistakably Fat Witch. The perfect everyday companion for fans of our legendary brownies. Listed at $13.00 on fatwitch.com.
- Fat Witch Tote Bag - $5: Carry your goodies in style—with a bag that’s as fun and practical as New York itself! This bright yellow tote is perfect for everyday use and built to be reused again and again. Size: 18" x 14" x…
- MIIR FW Logo Camp Cup - $28: Keep your drinks hot (or cold) and your style on point with our insulated 12-ounce camp mug! Featuring the iconic Fat Witch Bakery logo, it’s perfect for coffee, tea, or whatever fuels your day.…
- Bake Sale Cookbook #2 - $23: 67 delicious recipes from your favorite bakery—perfect for your next bake sale, party, or just baking up some magic at home! Listed at $23.00 on fatwitch.com.
- Witchy Tiny Bags - $63.50: A magical treat in every bag! Each of the 8 tiny bags contains 2 assorted baby brownies, packed with our signature flavors. Perfect for sharing, gifting, or enjoying a little brownie magic, these…
- Baby Zen Box - $16.50: Find harmony in every bite. This beautifully curated gift features four Japanese-inspired Fat Witch Baby flavors: rich Fat Witch Original, nutty Sesame, earthy Matcha, and bright, citrusy Yuzu. A…
- Tiny Bag B&W - $9.50: The perfect party favor! This mini gift comes with 1 Fat Witch Baby and 1 Blonde Baby, tucked inside our signature NYC Tiny Bag. Includes: 1 Fat Witch Baby & 1 Blonde Baby. Listed at $9.50 on…
- Classic Cauldron Special - $28.50: A magical mix of 8 brownie babies—Fat, Caramel, Blonde, Walnut, and Double Chocolate—all wrapped up and ready to charm your taste buds! Includes: 2 Fat Witch Babies, 2 Blonde Babies, 2 Double…
- Baby Gift Box - $27.50: The perfect gift to say thank you. The box is tied with ribbon and filled with delicious individually wrapped all chocolate brownies. Small things come in good packages! Listed at $27.50 on…
- Big Witch Box - $43.50: Sampler: 2 Fat Witch, Blonde Witch, Walnut Witch, Caramel Witch, Coffee Witch, Double Chocolate Witch, & Snow Witch. Box of Favs: 2 Fat Witches, 1 Blonde Witch, 2 Walnut Witches, 2 Caramel Witches &…
- 4 Baby Gift Tin - $19.50: Our signature black-and-white Skyline Tin, filled with four baby-sized brownies—a perfect gift or treat for yourself! Four little brownies packed into a cute tin—perfect for when you need a sweet…
- Fat Witch Baby - $3.50: This is where the magic began. Our original brownie — rich, satisfying, and deeply chocolatey — made for those moments when only a true classic will do. Listed at $3.50 on fatwitch.com.
- Witch Jute Market Bag - $18: Carry a little magic with you! Our Witch Tote is a sturdy, ecofriendly jute bag featuring the iconic Fat Witch New York logo. Perfect for groceries, books, or everyday essentials, this tote combines…
- Brownie Mix Original - $8.50: Bake the classic Fat Witch brownie at home! Rich and perfectly chocolatey, it’s the ultimate treat for cozy moments and homemade indulgence. Listed at $8.50 on fatwitch.com.
- Apple Cinnamon Baby - $3.50: Sweet, spiced, and full of fall flavor, this brownie brings the warm taste of apple and cinnamon in every bite. Listed at $3.50 on fatwitch.com.
- MiiR FW Logo Flip Traveler - $30: Take your favorite drinks on the go in style with our colorful Miir Travel Flip 12oz featuring the iconic Fat Witch Bakery logo and an all-over playful brownie design. Bright, bold, and irresistibly…
- 9 Baby All Star - $32.50: Can’t decide? Now you don’t have to! The 9 Baby All Star brings together 9 of our most beloved Baby Brownies so you can taste them all: 2 Fat Witch, plus Blonde, Double Chocolate, Caramel, Snow…
- Witch Ends Fat Witch Original - $9: Witch Ends Fat Witch Original is a 7oz bag of the chewy, crusty edges from our classic Fat Witch Original brownies. These are the most sought-after pieces, packed with rich chocolate flavor and a…
- Peanut Butter Baby - $3.50: Our rich, fudgy Baby Witch meets creamy peanut butter. A classic combination you won’t want to miss! Listed at $3.50 on fatwitch.com.
- Build A Witch At Home - $30.50: Build your own Fat Witch right from the comfort of your kitchen with 4 Baby Brownies, 2 Fat Witch Babies and 2 Snow Babies, plus mini jars of Coop’s Fudge and Coop’s Salted Caramel Sauce. Assemble…
- Brownie Bites - $5: Rich brownie bites coated in a smooth layer of chocolate for an easy, satisfying treat. Simple, indulgent, and perfectly portioned, they’re great for snacking, sharing, or adding to a gift box. A…