Betty Bakery
- Type: Artisan Food Producer
- Category: Bakery
- Location: Brooklyn, New York
A touch of retro & modern, a tribute to all that is mid-century mien & deliciousness; baked goods like treats that came out of our grandma’s kitchen, updated.
Products (60)
- Chocolate Covered Candied Almonds - $7.50: Roasted, candied almonds covered in dark chocolate and cocoa powder. Gluten Free. Sold in 4 oz jars Listed at $7.50 on bettybakery.com.
- Chocolate Almond Cake (GF) - $75: Our 2 layer Gluten Free chocolate almond cake with your choice of filling and icings. Create the Gluten Free chocolate cake of your dreams. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply…
- Savory 4 pie box set - $25: Discounted individual hand pies in four count sets, sold frozen. Select your favorites: 4 x Steak & Cheese Pies 4 x Beef Shepherd's Pies 4 x Argentine Empanada Pies 4 x Cumin Lamb Pies 4 x Thai…
- Gender Reveal Cake - $75: Our Gender Reveal Cake keeps the secret safe until it is sliced. Frosted in smooth vanilla buttercream and showered with cheerful rainbow sprinkles, this cake stays perfectly neutral on the…
- Gender Reveal Cupcakes - $5: Our Gender Reveal cupcake keeps the secret safe until you bite into it. You choose the cake and icing so the cupcake stays perfectly neutral on the outside—no hints, no spoilers, no accidental…
- Cheese Cake - Large - $65: Betty Bakery's signature moist Brooklyn cheese cake. Listed at $65.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Vegan Chocolate Cupcake - $5: Our tasty eggless chocolate cake with chocolate vegan ganache made with coconut milk. Comes with rainbow sprinkles. Listed at $5.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Unicorn Cake - $205: Who doesn't love unicorns! Behold, the fantastical unicorn cake, a mystical creation that will enchant your taste buds and imagination alike! Decorated with a mane of swirling pastel rosettes, o ur…
- Chocolate Orange Bundt Cake - $55: Indulge in our decadent Chocolate Orange Bundt Cake. Featured in a New York Times write-up, this confectionery marvel boasts a rich, moist crumb infused with the harmonious essence of premium dark…
- Holiday Cookie Tin - $50: Our famous holiday cookie tin. Contains: Chocolate Almond Leaves Lemon Shortbread Maple leaves Sugar Stars Chocolate trees Gingerbread Men Russian Tea Cookies Approx 18oz (a bit more than a lb), in…
- Large Gingerbread Men - $12: Large, decorated Gingerbread men. 9" tall Can be personalized upon request. Listed at $12.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Old Fashioned Apple Cake - $75: This cake is a sleeper. It's creamy, filled with fresh apples and baked to perfection. It looks simple, but it packs a complex punch that will make your guests go "Wow"! The 10" cake serves 10-12…
- Unicorn Cupcakes - $7: Your choice of cake filled with sprinkles and topped with colorful swirled vanilla frosting an edible sugar unicorn horn & ears! Listed at $7.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Award Winning Brown Butter Pumpkin Pie - 10" - $50: A Thanksgiving classic. Our Pumpkin Pie was the winner of 2018's best of Pumpkin Pie contest. Our combination of spices and slow cooked pumpkin make this the best pumpkin pie you could bring to your…
- Blueberry Pie - 10" - $55: Nothing beats our Blueberry Pie! Ripe, luscious blueberries mixed with a proprietary blend of butter and spices, baked in our flaky pastry and topped with our buttery streusel topping. A year round…
- Chocolate Chunk Pecan Pie - 10" - $60: Two great tastes that taste great together! We improve on our Pecan Pie by adding a heaping serving of bittersweet chocolate to the mix. What's not to love? Listed at $60.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Double Crust Apple Pie - 10" - $65: The classic apple pie taken to a new level. Using locally grown apples sourced from the Hudson Valley our Apple Pie is a chorus of vanilla, brown butter and spices in our famous, flaky crust. Listed…
- NY Sour Cherry Pie - 10" - $55: Scrumptious sour cherries lightly spiced in our all butter double crusted pie shell. Listed at $55.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Pecan Pie -10" - $55: Our all natural pecan pie consists of toasted, buttery pecans blended with our classic pecan pie custard mix. Made without Corn Syrup, our pecan pie has a deep caramel flavor that isn't overly sweet…
- Hudson Valley Dutch Apple Pie - 10" - $50: The classic apple pie taken to a new level. Using locally grown apples sourced from the Hudson Valley our Apple Pie is a chorus of vanilla, brown butter and spices, topped with our famous buttery &…
- Pumpkin Pie (Lactose Free) -10" - $58: Made with coconut milk, this creamy pumpkin pie's special combination of spices and slow cooked pumpkin makes it a great addition to your holiday meals! Listed at $58.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Violet Sweet Potato Pie -10" - $65: If you like Pumpkin pie, you'll love our new Violet Sweet Potato Pie! Made with Japanese Purple Sweet Potatoes, imported from Japan, our Sweet Potato pie is not only sweet and savory, but the violet…
- Valentine Ring Dings - $7.50: Our classic ring ding in heat shapes. Listed at $7.50 on bettybakery.com.
- Filling - $5: Listed at $5.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Lemon Almond Torte - $65: Moist lemony cake decorated with candied lemon peel and toasted sliced almonds (Parve - no flour, no butter) Listed at $65.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Coconut Macaroons - $12: Coconut Macaroons specially crafted for Passover! Indulge in the heavenly taste of our Coconut Macaroons this Passover and make your celebrations even sweeter. Place your order now and treat…
- Chocolate Almond Ring Dings (GF) - $7.50: Our Gluten Free version of the retro classic snack cake. Chocolate almond cake sandwiched with vanilla buttercream and raspberry jam, dipped in chocolate. topped with candied almonds Listed at $7.50…
- Neopolitan Cake - $80: Vanilla cake. Strawberry buttercream w/ a layer of chocolate ganache, iced with a swirl of vanilla buttercream and chocolate ganache. Listed at $80.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Flourless Chocolate Cake - $70: Our flourless chocolate cake has a dense, moist texture halfway between a brownie and a cake that melts in your mouth with every forkful. Whether you're treating yourself to a luxurious dessert or…
- Chocolate Cake w/Vanilla buttercream - $75: Our signature Valrhona chocolate cake meets its match in silky vanilla buttercream — a pairing so classic, it’s practically a love story. Each bite strikes the perfect balance of deep cocoa and…
- Lemon Lavender Cake - $80: Imagine diving into 3 layers of zesty lemon cake paired with creamy lemon buttercream, tangy lemon curd, and topped with a delightful lemon lavender buttercream. It's the perfect mix of sweet and…
- Orange Creamsicle Cake - $70: Wow! You've got to try our new Orange Creamsicle. It tastes like summer should! 3 layers of our orange cake, filled with creamy orange and vanilla buttercream, filled with orange curd for a punch of…
- Paint-Your-Own-Cookie Cookies - $6.95: Vanilla butter cookies with cute stenciled decorations, food color "paint" and a paint brush. Just add water and paint in the fun! Listed at $6.95 on bettybakery.com.
- Rugelach (per lb) - $38: Please note that the quantity refers to weight. There is an average of 12-14 pieces of rugelach per pound. Listed at $38.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Decorated Holiday Cookies - Thanksgiving - $12: Listed at $12.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Snowman Cake - $75: Listed at $75.00 on bettybakery.com.
- Carrot Cake Cupcake - $4.50: Listed at $4.50 on bettybakery.com.
- Chocolate / Chocolate Cupcake - $4.50: Chocolate cake with mocha cream cheese Listed at $4.50 on bettybakery.com.
- Chocolate / Strawberry Cupcake - $4.50: Chocolate Cake with Strawberry Buttercream Listed at $4.50 on bettybakery.com.
- Chocolate / Vanilla Cupcake - $4.50: Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream Listed at $4.50 on bettybakery.com.
Menu
- Carrot Cake Slice - $9.25: Carrot cake with cream cheese filling & icing.
- Brazilian Chicken Pie - $9.00: Tender pieces of all-natural chicken in a Cuban-inspired sofrito, with fresh peas, carrots, and coconut milk. Enjoy!
- Thai Chicken Pie - $9.00: For people who like a little spice. Tender pieces of all natural chicken, mushrooms, peas, carrots, ginger & lemon grass in a slightly…
- Curry Vegetable Pie - $8.50: There is no better way to get your vegetables than in a pie! Cauliflower florets, fresh peas, crispy broccoli, succulent mushrooms…
- Rustic Pie - $7.00
- Twinkie - $4.50: Our version of the retro classic. Vanilla sponge cake filled with a creamy vanilla buttercream center.
- Vanilla Strawberry Cupcake - $4.50
- Red Velvet Cupcake - $4.50: Moist red velvet cake with layers of rich cream cheese frosting and a hint of cocoa.
- Carrot Cake Cupcake - $4.50
- Chocolate Vanilla Cupcake - $4.50
- Chocolate Chocolate Cupcake - $4.50: Rich chocolate cupcake topped with chocolate frosting and colorful sprinkles.
- Vanilla Chocolate Cupcake - $4.50
- Shepherd's Pie - $10.00: Whether you call it a Shepherd's Pie or a Cottage Pie, our version of this classic pie has quickly become a cult classic. Made with lean…
- Carrot Cake - $1.00: Between each layer of this delightful cake is a generous slathering of velvety cream cheese frosting. This luscious frosting is made from…
- Valrhona Chocolate Cake - $1.00: Nestled between and covering 3 luscious chocolate layers is a sumptuous mocha cream cheese filling. This filling combines the slight…
- Red Velvet - $1.00: Between each vibrant red layer is a generous spread of luxurious cream cheese frosting. This frosting is crafted from the finest cream…
- Valrhona Chocolate Cake - $1.00: Nestled between and covering 3 luscious chocolate layers is a sumptuous mocha cream cheese filling. This filling combines the slight…
- Carrot Cake - $1.00: Between each layer of this delightful cake is a generous slathering of velvety cream cheese frosting. This luscious frosting is made from…
- Red Velvet - $1.00: Between each vibrant red layer is a generous spread of luxurious cream cheese frosting. This frosting is crafted from the finest cream…
- Carrot Cake Slice - $9.25: Carrot cake with cream cheese filling & icing.
- Red Velvet Cake Slice - $9.25: Lush version of the classic cake with cream cheese filling & icing.
- Valrhona Chocolate Cake Slice - $9.25: Valrhona chocolate cake with chocolate mocha cream cheese filling and icing.
- Old Fashioned Apple Cake Slice - $6.50: Rustic cake with a creamy center and crackly top. Filled with sliced apples.
- Lemon Bundt Cake Slice - $6.50
- Mini - Cheesecake - $7.00: Mini cheesecake available in plain or chocolate flavor.
- Vanilla Strawberry Cupcake - $4.50
- Red Velvet Cupcake - $4.50: Moist red velvet cake with layers of rich cream cheese frosting and a hint of cocoa.
- Carrot Cake Cupcake - $4.50
- Vanilla Vanilla Cupcake - $4.50
- Chocolate Vanilla Cupcake - $4.50
- Chocolate Strawberry Cupcake - $4.50
- Vanilla Chocolate Cupcake - $4.50
- Chocolate Chocolate Cupcake - $4.50: Rich chocolate cupcake topped with chocolate frosting and colorful sprinkles.
- Argentine Empanada - $9.00: This savory pie is filled with ground beef, red and green peppers, green olives, and Argentine spices.
- Bacon Egg & Cheese Pie - $7.00: Perfect for people looking for a quality breakfast option. Whole egg baked in a house-made shakshuka (garlic, jalapeno, onions, red…
- Brazilian Chicken Pie - $9.00: Tender pieces of all-natural chicken in a Cuban-inspired sofrito, with fresh peas, carrots, and coconut milk. Enjoy!
- Curry Vegetable Pie - $8.50: There is no better way to get your vegetables than in a pie! Cauliflower florets, fresh peas, crispy broccoli, succulent mushrooms…
- Cumin Lamb Pie - $10.00: Ground lamb cooked with onions, garlic, Chinese red chilis, Sichuan pepper and loads of spices. This one has a lot of ma la!
- Moroccan Breakfast Pie - $7.00: Perfect for people looking for a quality breakfast option. Whole egg baked in a house-made shashuka (garlic, jalapeno, onions, red pepper…
- Shepherd's Pie - $10.00: Whether you call it a Shepherd's Pie or a Cottage Pie, our version of this classic pie has quickly become a cult classic. Made with lean…
- Spinach Egg & Cheese Pie - $7.00: This savory pie is filled with ground beef, red and green peppers, green olives, and Argentine spices.
- Steak & Cheese Pie - $11.50: For people who love meat and cheese this is the pie for you. Braised, all natural short rib seasoned with rosemary, thyme and caramelized…
- Thai Chicken Pie - $9.00: For people who like a little spice. Tender pieces of all natural chicken, mushrooms, peas, carrots, ginger & lemon grass in a slightly…
- Rustic Pie - $7.00
- Dutch Apple Pie Hand Pie - $7.00: Hand Pie. Apple pie filling encased in a flaky crust. Option for hand pie size.
- Blueberry Pie (4.5") - $7.00
- Classic Ring Ding - $7.00: Our version of the retro classic snack cake. Chocolate cake sandwiched with vanilla buttercream, dipped in chocolate.
- Nutella Ring Ding - $7.25: Valrhona chocolate cake sandwiched with Nutella & Nutella buttercream & dipped in dark chocolate, with a hazelnut garnish.
- Small Cookies by the Pound - $1.00: Selection of small cookies: Chocolate Chip Red Velvet Lemon Stars Oatmeal Confetti
- The Curly Brunette - $3.95
- The Waldo - $4.25
- Chocolate Chip - $3.95: A classic cookie featuring rich chocolate chips embedded in a soft, chewy dough.
- Red Velvet Cookie - $3.95
- Oatmeal Raisin - $3.95
- Blondie - $3.95
- Walnut Brownie - $3.95
- Chocolate Brownie (no nuts) - $3.95: Rich chocolate brownie with a soft, fudgy center and chocolate chips, free from nuts.
- Lemon Coconut Bar - $3.95
- Rice Krispy Treats - $4.25: Brown butter rice krispy treats - an updated spin on a classic.
- Twinkie - $4.50: Our version of the retro classic. Vanilla sponge cake filled with a creamy vanilla buttercream center.
- Rice Krispy Treats - $4.25: Brown butter rice krispy treats - an updated spin on a classic.
- Classic Ring Ding - $7.00: Our version of the retro classic snack cake. Chocolate cake sandwiched with vanilla buttercream, dipped in chocolate.
- Nutella Ring Ding - $7.25: Valrhona chocolate cake sandwiched with Nutella & Nutella buttercream & dipped in dark chocolate, with a hazelnut garnish.