Buttermilk Bakeshop
- Type: Artisan Food Producer
- Category: Bakery
- Location: New York, New York
Brooklyn bakery offering custom cakes, cookies, and pastries. Local pickup in Park Slope and Gowanus and nationwide delivery.
News and blog (6)
- Because Life Isn’t Always Planned (But Cake Can Be): As a mom of two, I understand messy houses, crazy schedules, and how small moments can slip by faster than you expect. One minute you’re thinking about…
- Custom Cakes in Brooklyn: Why Pricing Isn’t Always Straightforward: One of the number one questions I get asked is, “How much does that cake cost?” And honestly… it’s a big question. It’s almost limitless. Like trying to write…
- The Magic of Watching Kids Bake & Party, Brooklyn Style. No Magician Needed, at Buttermilk’s Kid’s Parties in Gowanus.: From little birthdays to tweens, it’s all about the kids — even the ones who think ‘I’m not good at this’ — and for parents, it’s about watching the party…
- Weddings Are Evolving — and We’re Listening Closely.: If you’ve talked to anyone planning a wedding in 2026 , you already know: The mood has changed. Gone are the “blowout or bust” wedding plans. Gone are the…
- Loving Brooklyn Grace as Much as its Grit: Admittedly, it’s a little rough around the edges sometimes. The subways screech, the rent’s high, the stoops have opinions. But that’s the beauty of sharing a…
- Oh, For the Love of Cookies: A love letter to the treat that holds our memories, our moments, and a little Brooklyn magic. There’s something about a cookie that just lands differently.…
Menu
- Buttermilk Biscuits - $22.50: Buttermilk Original Buttermilk Pie
- Caramel Apple Walnut - $47.00: Classic Pumpkin Pie
- Double Crusted Apple Pie - $46.00: Festive Cake Pops
- Gluten Free Pies - $48.10: Half & Half Pie
- Salted Nutella Pecan Pie - $5.75: Sour Cherry Pie
- Cakes Available In Store Today - $50.00: Classic Birthday Cake (Large)
- GF options - $50.00: Strawberry Shortcake Cake
- GF options - $60.00: Rainbow Cake (Large)
- GF options - $50.00: Pistachio Honey Cake
- GF options - $60.70: Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Buttercream
- Photo Cake - $95.00: Red Velvet Cake
- GF options - $52.09: Pre-order (min 2 days notice )
- GF options - $35.60: Cookies & Milk Cake
- GF options - $60.00: Coconut Passion Fruit Cake
- GF options - $62.09: Cranberry Carrot Cake
- Ding Dong Cake - $60.00: Lemon Lavender Cake
- Oreo! - $60.00: Pistachio Raspberry Cake
- GF options - $62.70: The Wedding Slice Cake
- GF options - $60.70
- Vegan Cake - $70.10: Custom Cakes
- Seasonal Bar Box - $19.40
- Bar Box - $4.85
- Brookie - $4.85
- Brownie - $4.85: Chocolate Covered Oreos
- Gluten Free / Vegan Peanut Butter Bar - $4.85
- Lemon Bar - $4.85: Sour Cherry Almond Bar
- Strawberry Linzer - $4.85: Vegan Brownie Bar
- Whoopie Pies - $5.70: Order a box of our freshly baked cookies now. Choose from the core flavors and we will have the box ready for pick up at the bakery!
- Cupcake Box - $4.35: Vegan Cupcake Box
- Red Velvet with Cream Cheese Frosting - $4.35: Apple Crumble Cupcake
- DIY Cupcakes - $49.20: Gluten Free Cupcake Box
- Rainbow Candles - $4.50: Gold Candles
- Happy Birthday Cake Topper - $7.50: Number Candle
- Rose Gold Candles - $4.50: French Macarons
- Buttermilk Original Buttermilk Pie - $5.50: Caramel Apple Walnut
- Classic Pecan Pie - $39.80: Classic Pumpkin Pie
- Salted Nutella Pecan Pie - $5.75: Assorted Cake Pops
- Push Up Pops - $70.10: Mini Cupcake Box
- Mini Bar Box - $43.89: The Little Celebration Box
- Deluxe Sweet Treats Platter - $132.77: The Party Starter
- The Sweet Sampler - $45.00: Cake In A Jar
- Birthday Card - $6.10