Mama's Custom Cookies
- Type: Artisan Food Producer
- Category: Bakery
- Location: Wantagh, New York
Bakery in Wantagh, NY.
Products (36)
- Cookie Designer: Show us your vision! Upload images, add text, choose fonts, colors, and shapes and send us your design or save for later! Listed on mamascustomcookies.com.
- Welcome Baby Boy! - $40: Celebrate the sweetest little arrival with an adorable cookie collection made just for baby boy! Contains 6 cookies. Ingredients: Flour, Sugar, Butter, Salt, Vanilla Royal Icing Mix – Confectioner’s…
- Welcome Baby Girl! - $40: Celebrate the sweetest little arrival with an adorable cookie collection made just for baby girl! Contains 6 cookies. Ingredients: Flour, Sugar, Butter, Salt, Vanilla Royal Icing Mix –…
- Expecting Baby - $22: The sweetest way to announce, celebrate, or surprise someone with your exciting baby news! 3 cookie set. *ALSO AVAILABLE IN BLUE; Request which color you would like in text below* Ingredients…
- Rubber Ducky - $7.50: Crafted with precision and a touch of whimsy, our Rubber Ducky Cookies are the perfect treat to add a splash of joy to any occasion. Whether you're celebrating a baby shower, a birthday, or just…
- Champagne Birthday - $48: Pop the cork it is time to celebrate! Ingredients: Flour, Sugar, Butter, Salt, Vanilla Royal Icing Mix – Confectioner’s Sugar, Corn Starch, Egg Whites, Gum Arabic, Tartar, Vanillin MADE ON EQUIPMENT…
- Cheers and Beers Birthday Set - $48: Cheers & Beers Birthday Cookie Set Raise a glass to another great year with our festive beer-mug birthday cookie collection. This set features frothy, hand-decorated beer mugs paired with…
- Fire Truck - $8: Calling all heroes in training! Our Fire Truck Custom Cookies are the perfect way to ignite excitement at your next event. Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, a special occasion, or simply want…
- Happy Birthday Cupcake - $15: Celebrate their special day with our delightful Happy Birthday Cupcake cookie set! These cookies are not just a treat for the taste buds, but also a heartfelt way to show someone you care. Imagine…
- Bee Well Soon - $36: Brighten someone’s day with a sweet “Bee Well” bouquet—no vase needed! Our Bee Well Cookie Set is a vibrant and delicious way to send healing vibes. Featuring colorful flowers, a personalized name…
- Speedy Recovery - $32: Our “Speedy Recovery” cookie set is the perfect way to lift someone’s spirits after an injury or surgery! 4 cookie set. Ingredients: Flour, Sugar, Butter, Eggs, Salt, Vanilla Royal Icing Mix –…
- New Home Set - $42: Celebrate a new chapter with our New Home Cookie Set! This beautiful 5-cookie collection is a sweet and thoughtful way to congratulate new homeowners as they settle into their new space. Each cookie…
- Thanks for helping me grow - $22: Celebrate the guiding hands and nurturing hearts of teachers and mothers alike with our "Thank You for Helping Me Grow" cookie set. Each meticulously crafted cookie is a sweet expression of…
- Sunshine & Thank You - $28: Brighten Someone’s Day with Our Sunshine & Thanks Cookie Set! 🌻☀️ Say “thank you” in the sweetest way possible with this cheerful 4-cookie set featuring sunny smiles, bold sunflowers, and…
- Thank You Nurses! - $42: Say thank you to your favorite nurse with this adorable 6 cookie set! Ingredients: Flour, Sugar, Butter, Eggs, Salt, Vanilla Royal Icing Mix – Confectioner’s Sugar, Corn Starch, Egg Whites, Gum…
- Engagement Celebration Cookie Set - $16: Celebrate one of life’s sweetest moments with our elegant engagement cookie duo. Featuring a beautifully detailed proposal silhouette and a personalized message cookie, this set is the perfect way…
- Congratulations Mr. + Mrs. - $75: Our custom wedding cookies are handcrafted to match your special day—down to the date, colors, and personal touches. From champagne bottles to florals, each cookie is as beautiful as it is…
- He Asked…She Said Yes - $48: Celebrate the magic of “yes” with our handcrafted engagement cookie set—a delicious gift for the newly engaged couple to savor! Designed to sweeten their milestone, these cookies feature elegant…
- Bucket of Popcorn Cookies - $20: Movie night just got a whole lot sweeter with our custom popcorn cookies! Perfectly displayed in p lastic popcorn reusable container , these buttery treats look just like the real thing – but way…
- Dance Recital Bouquet - $24: 👯♀️🩰Step into the spotlight with our Custom Cookie Dance Recital Bouquet! 💐 Delightfully crafted for your special performer, it's a treat for both the eyes and taste buds.👯♀️🩰 Bouquet is 3…
- Celebrate Sweet Success! - $24: Our 3-cookie graduation bouquet is the perfect way to say “Congratulations!”—complete with a custom name plaque, smiley grad emoji, and star cookie with cap. Wrapped and ready to gift, it’s a fun…
- Get Your Mahj On! (16 Cookies) - $25: Get Your Mahj On with this adorable bite-size Mahjong Cookie Set! This playful collection includes 16 screen-printed mini cookies designed to resemble classic Mahjong tiles. Perfect for Mahjong…
- Get Your Mahj On! (30 Cookies) - $45: Get Your Mahj On with this adorable bite-size Mahjong Cookie Set! This playful collection includes 30 screen-printed mini cookies designed to resemble classic Mahjong tiles. Perfect for Mahjong…
- Disney Princess Dress-Up Cookie Rack - $60: Bring a little fairytale magic to any celebration with our Princess Closet Cookie Collection! This enchanting set includes 6 beautifully decorated princess-inspired dress cookies , each featuring…
- Dot Cookie - $3.50: Add a little extra sweetness to any occasion with our Classic Dot Cookie! This simple yet playful cookie features our signature sugar cookie topped with a cheerful dot design, making it an easy…
- Welcome Back Elf - $6: Guess who's back from the North Pole?! 🎄❤️ Make your elf's grand return extra sweet with our Personalized Welcome Back Elf Cookie! This adorable round cookie features a festive little elf and a…
- Dumpling Thanksgiving Paintable - $6: Get ready to paint up some Thanksgiving magic with our Dumpling Squishy Paint Your Own Cookie Kit! This adorable square cookie features a Thanksgiving-themed Dumpling Squishy design just waiting to…
- Thanksgiving DIY Kit - $22: Get creative this Thanksgiving with our Thanksgiving DIY Cookie Decorating Kit! This fun, hands-on kit includes 6 delicious cookies—2 pie slices, 2 turkey legs, and 2 turkeys—all ready to decorate!…
- Thanksgiving Dinner Leftovers - $15: Thanksgiving leftovers have never looked so sweet! Who says the best part of Thanksgiving has to wait until the next day?! Our Thanksgiving Leftovers Cookie Set puts a sweet twist on everyone's…
- All The Fixins' Thanksgiving Platter - $45: All the Thanksgiving fixin's, without any of the cooking! 🦃🥧🤎 Bring a little extra sweetness to the Thanksgiving table with our All The Fixins' Thanksgiving Platter! This adorable platter features…
- Fall Platter - $45: Celebrate the cozy colors of fall with our Fall Platter! This festive platter features 30 assorted bite-size cookies inspired by all the little things we love about fall! Featuring colorful leaves…
- Mystery Thanksgiving Dumpling - $6: A little mystery, a whole lot of Thanksgiving sweetness! 🦃🥟🍂 Get ready for a festive surprise with our Thanksgiving Mystery Dumpling Squishy Cookie! Inspired by the adorable mystery dumpling squishy…
- Turkey Leg Sleeve - $8: Gobble up something sweet this Thanksgiving with our Turkey Leg Cookie Sleeve! 🦃🍗🤎 This adorable set includes 4 bite-size cookies decorated to look like mini turkey legs! A fun and festive twist on…
- Happy Thanksgiving Paintable - $6: Get ready to paint up some Thanksgiving magic with our ' Happy Thanksgiving' Paint Your Own Cookie Kit! This adorable square cookie features a Thanksgiving-themed design just waiting to come to life…
- '6 7' Turkey Paintable - $6: Get ready to paint up some Thanksgiving magic with our 6 7 Turkey Paint Your Own Cookie Kit! This adorable square cookie features a Thanksgiving-themed 6 7 design just waiting to come to life with a…
- Game Day Platter - $45: It's GAME DAY, and we're bringing the sweetness to the sidelines! 🏈🤎 Get ready for kickoff with our Game Day Football Cookie Platter! This game day favorite features an assortment of adorable…