Cattlemen's Steakhouse
- Type: Restaurant
- Category: BBQ Joint
- Location: Port Jefferson Station, New York
- Cuisine: Steakhouse
Our steaks are the heart of our restaurant, and they are hand-cut in-house every day with care, precision, and pride. This hands-on approach is what sets Cattlemen's Steakhouse apart and what has earned us a reputation for serving some of the best steaks around. Quality matters to us, so nothing leaves our kitchen unless it meets the standards, serving only what we would proudly put in front of our own friends and family. Alongside our steaks, our thoughtfully prepared cocktails are crafted to complement every meal and elevate the overall experience at both of our locations - Mountain Grove and Willow Springs.
Menu
- Shrimp Cocktail - $18.00: Jumbo shrimp served with cocktail sauce
- Feed Trough Fries - $14.00: French fries topped with shaved prime rib, and queso cheese
- Fried Pickles Chips - $13.00: Zesty kosher pickle chips battered and deep fried, served with house dressing
- Spinach Dip - $13.00: House-made spinach dip with artichokes and melted parmesan, served with tortilla chips
- Potstickers - $13.00: Deep-fried pork dumplings, shredded cabbage, and scallions, served with sweet chili sauce
- Garlic Parmesan Fries - $10.00: Our battered French fries tossed in garlic parmesan. Served with garlic dipping sauce
- Garlic Cheese Curds - $13.00: Real Wisconsin cheese, battered in breadcrumbs and garlic, served with house dressing
- Fried Mushrooms - $13.00: Whole button mushrooms battered fresh in-house, served with house dressing
- Battered Green Beans - $12.00: Whole green beans with a toasted onion-flavored batter
- Onion Tanglers - $11.00: Onion slivers covered in a light, scratch-style breading
- Pulled Pork Nachos - $14.00: Tortilla chips topped with baked beans, smoked pulled pork, queso cheese, BBQ sauce, sour cream, green onions, and jalapeños
- Ounce Drover - $29.00 | 16 Ounce $46.00 • Our most flavorful cut, perfectly: Angus Top Sirloin
- Angus Steak Tips - $26.00: Sirloin Steak Tips sautéed with red onions and bell peppers
- Angus Filet Mignon - $40.00: Eight-ounce cut of our most tender steak, hand-cut and wrapped in bacon
- oz Manhattan - $27.00 | 14 oz $39.00 • Fourteen ounces of lean, slightly ma: 16 oz T-Bone
- Angus Petit Filet Mignon - $32.00: Parmesan encrusted 12 oz tender and juicy ribeye
- Chicken - $20.00 | Steak $24.00 | Shrimp $28.00 • Mixed greens, chedda: Entrée Caesar Salad
- Salad only - $6.00 | Chicken $12.00 | Shrimp $19.00 | Steak $15.00
- Soup only - $7.00 | Soup and Salad $13.00 | Soup with Grilled Cheese $13: Burgers & Sandwiches
- The 'Beast Burger' - $21.00: 1/2 pound wagyu, venison, bison and wild boar char-grilled to perfection and topped with melted cheddar, lettuce, onion, tomato, and pickle
- Cowboy Bison Burger - $20.00: Ground bison topped with bacon, onion tanglers, cheddar cheese, and hickory BBQ sauce on a toasted bun
- Cheeseburger - $15.00: Ground Angus covered in melted cheddar topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on a toasted bun | Add bacon +$2.00
- Single - $13.00 | Double $15.00 | Triple $17.00 • Angus burger smashe: Oklahoma Smash Burger
- Single - $11.00 | Double $14.00 | Tripple $17.00 • Angus Beef Patty t: Pulled Pork on Bun
- Single - $14.00 | Double $17.00 | Triple $20.00 • Angus Beef Patty to: Bruiser Smash Burger
- Single - $13.00 | Double $16.00 | Tripple $19.00 • Angus Beef Patty t: Prime Rib Sandwich
- Single - $14.00 | Double $17.00 | Triple $20.00 • Smashed beef patty,: Chicken Sandwich
- Pulled Pork Sandwich - $18.00: Smoked pulled pork on a toasted bun and served with your choice of hickory BBQ or our sweet heat BBQ
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap - $16.00: Grilled or Fried chicken, lettuce, cheddar cheese, tomato, and chopped bacon with house dressing, in spinach tortilla wrap
- Chicken Bourbon Wrap - $16.00: Grilled or fried chicken, lettuce, cheddar cheese, tomatoes, onion tanglers, and bourbon sauce wrapped in a spinach tortilla
- Prime Rib Sandwich - $19.00: Shaved prime rib, sautéed peppers and onions, and melted Swiss cheese on a hoagie. Served with au jus and horseradish sauce
- Cowboy Beef Melt - $19.00: Shaved prime rib, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and bacon aioli on a hoagie
- Fried Shrimp - $27.00: Hand-battered and served with made-in-house cocktail sauce
- Simply Grilled - $28.00 | Blackened $29.00 • Grilled in garlic butter and hou: Bourbon Glazed Salmon
- Simply Grilled - $18.00 | Bourbon Glazed $20.00 | Fried Pork Chop $19.00 | Ad: Country Fried Steak
- Beef - $24.00 | Chicken $22.00 • Traditional country fried steak de: Hot Roast Beef Dinner
- Simply Grilled - $20.00 | Blackened $21.00 | Hickory BBQ $21.00 | Bourbon Gla: Chicken Tender Dinner
- tenders - $18.00 | 4 tenders $21.00 • Option of 3 or 4 hand-breaded te: Catfish Dinner
- Pasta Only - $16.00 | Chicken $21.00 | Steak $26.00 | Shrimp $26.00 | Pul: Cowboy Pasta
- Pasta Only - $18.00 | Chicken $23.00 | Steak $27.00 | Shrimp $28.00 • Fet: House-Made Alfredo
- Pasta Only - $17.00 | Chicken $22.00 | Steak $26.00 | Shrimp $27.00 • Fet: Specialty Items
- Smoked Prime Rib - $18.00 | Smoked Pulled Pork $15.00 | BBQ Grilled Chicken $16: Smoked Prime Ribeye
- Price - $4.50: Baked Potato
- Loaded Baked Potato - $6.50: Loaded Mashed Potato
- Loaded Mac & Cheese - $7.00: Sweet Potato Fries
- Onion Tanglers - $6.50: Fried Green Beans
- Fried Pickles - $6.50: Fried Mushrooms
- Garlic Cheese Curds - $6.50: Garlic Parmesan Fries
- Carrot Fries - $6.50: Consumer Advisory: Consumption of undercooked meat, poultry, eggs, or seafood may increase the risk of foodborne illnesses. Please alert…
- Tiramisu Cake - $8.00: A classic Italian dessert made with espresso
- Molten Lava Cake - $10.00: A decadent, rich chocolate cake oozing with
- Orange Phyllo Cake - $8.00: A traditional Greek dessert made with phyllo pastry, Greek yogurt, and sweetened orange pulp, topped with sweet orange slices and finished…
- Western Grilled Steak Salad - $18.00: Sliced, seasoned and grilled tender steak with tomatoes, cucumber, onion, cheddar cheese, and croutons ,on a bed of lettuce. Pairs well…
- Grilled Chicken Salad - $17.00: Seasoned grilled chicken breast, tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, cheddar cheese, and croutons, served on a bed of lettuce. Pairs well with…
- Pulled Pork Quesadilla - $16.00: Smoked Pulled Pork served in a large 12 inch grilled flour tortilla with shredded cheddar cheese and BBQ sauce. Served with side of sour…
- Lunch Portion Chicken Alfredo - $14.00: Choice of grilled or fried Chicken served on a bed of fettuccine covered in a rich, creamy Alfredo sauce. Served with a house salad.
- Fried Catfish & French Fries - $12.00: Chicken Strips & French Fries
- Pulled Pork Stuffed Spud - $12.00: Baked potato loaded with butter, sour cream, cheddar, smoked pulled pork, bacon, and chives, served with hickory or sweet heat BBQ.
- Single - $13.00 | Double $16.00 | Tripple $19.00 • Angus Beef Patty w: Cowboy Beef Melt
- The Ultimate BLT - $12.00: Layers of crisp hickory-smoked bacon topped with fresh-sliced tomatoes, crisp leaf lettuce, and mayo on grilled texas toast.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap - $13.00: Chicken Bourbon Wrap
- COCKTAILS - $6.00: • Stumpwater
- APPETIZERS - $6.00: • Fried Pickle Chips
- Amaretto Sour - $4.00: Whiskey Sour
- Old Fashioned - $4.00: Whiskey & Coke
- Margaritas - $4.00: $1 Off Wines
- Cheesecake by - $6.99 | Cheesecake by the whole $45.99: NewYork Style Cheesecake
- By the Slice - $6.99
- By the Whole Pie - $39.99: Italian Cream Cake