Suprema
- Type: Restaurant
- Location: Rutherford, New Jersey
- Cuisine: Italian
Italian-American BYOB on Park Avenue in Rutherford, NJ. Lunch every day, dinner Wednesday to Sunday. Listing information from OpenStreetMap contributors (openstreetmap.org/copyright), used under the Open Database License.
Menu
- Rice balls a regular’s order - $15: Creamy risotto, mozzarella, basil pomodoro.
- Meatballs with ricotta - $18: Grass-fed beef, fresh ricotta, San Marzano, pecorino.
- Burrata - $24: Imported burrata, sweet roasted peppers, basil pesto.
- Mozzarella sticks - $17: Homemade mozzarella, grated pecorino, pomodoro.
- Lemon garlic shrimp - $25: Jumbo gulf shrimp, lemon & garlic butter sauce, Calabrian chili.
- Fried calamari - $24: Crispy domestic calamari, rice flour crust, arrabiata & house-made tartar.
- Cheesy garlic bread - $16: Thick-cut Italian bread, roasted garlic & herb olive oil, freshly grated pecorino, basil pomodoro.
- Whipped ricotta bruschetta dip - $18: Fresh local ricotta, roma tomatoes, basil, extra virgin olive oil, toasted crostini.
- Salads add chicken - $7, shrimp $9
- Caesar - $16: Gem lettuce, Reggiano, prosciutto crisps, soft-cooked egg, house-made croutons, creamy Caesar dressing.
- Artichoke house favorite - $16: Organic mixed greens, Roman artichokes, Reggiano parmesan, pistachio crumble, fresh lemon vinaigrette.
- Quinoa - $16: Organic mixed greens, quinoa, avocado, Marcona almonds, goat cheese, champagne vinaigrette.
- Apple blue cheese - $16: Organic mixed greens, Pink Lady apples, creamy blue cheese, golden raisins, roasted hazelnuts, white balsamic & honey.
- Suprema green - $14: Organic mixed greens, avocado, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, shaved fennel, shallots, champagne vinaigrette.
- Chicken Milanese - $24: Crispy Bell & Evans chicken cutlet, Mediterranean salad, olives, shallots, cherry tomatoes, Reggiano, balsamic vinaigrette.
- Salads half / full · add chicken - $7, shrimp $9
- Roast beef - $19: Shaved ribeye, warm mozzarella, charred garlic bread, beef jus.
- Chicken - $19: Crispy Bell & Evans chicken cutlet, house-made mozzarella, arugula, beefsteaks, aged balsamic, olive oil.
- Toscana - $18: Balsamic marinated eggplant, roasted red peppers, grilled zucchini, fresh mozzarella, basil pesto.
- Prosciutto - $19: Italian prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, sweet sundried peppers, fresh basil, garlic & olive oil, balsamic dressing.
- Turkey - $19: Roasted turkey, avocado, backyard tomatoes, arugula, house-made pesto mayo, sliced potato onion bread.
- Grilled chicken BLT - $19: Bell & Evans chicken breast, maple bacon, greens, marinated tomatoes, balsamic mayo, sliced sourdough.
- Waldorf chicken - $18: Hand-pulled chicken breast, grapes, apples, carrots, golden raisins, honey dijonnaise dressing, butter lettuce, toasted sourdough.
- Parmesan most ordered - $19: Bell & Evans chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, grated pecorino, garlic bread, choice of vodka or marinara sauce.
- Sausage - $19: Local fennel sausage, broccoli rabe, burrata, caramelized onions, balsamic reduction.
- Pasta add burrata - $5: Rigatoncini vodka the favorite
- Spaghetti pomodoro - $20: Spaghetti, Neapolitan pomodorini, sautéed garlic, extra virgin olive oil, basil & pecorino Romano.
- Spaghetti carbonara - $25: Spaghetti, cage-free eggs, pancetta, pecorino, cracked black pepper.
- Tagliatelle beef rib ragu - $34: Slow-simmered beef, Italian soffritto, milk, tomato passata, pecorino.
- Bucatini artichoke pesto - $26: Bucatini, fresh artichoke & pistachio pesto, lemon pecorino breadcrumb.
- Shrimp arrabiata - $32: Spaghetti, pan-sautéed shrimp, spicy Calabrian chilies, pomodoro sauce.
- Casarecci sausage & broccoli rabe - $26: Short-cut pasta, local fennel pork sausage, sautéed broccoli rabe, garlic & olive oil, fresh pecorino.
- Affogato - $15: Espresso over gelato.
- Tiramisu - $15: Mascarpone, eggs, espresso, amaretto, sponge cake, shaved chocolate.
- Chocolate layer cake - $15: Rich Valrhona chocolate, chocolate buttercream.
- New York cheesecake - $15
- Carrot cake - $15: Coffee & tea
- Espresso - $4.50
- Americano - $4.50
- Herbal tea - $4.50
- Latte - $5
- Cappuccino - $6
- French fries - $7: Truffle fries
- Broccoli rabe - $7
- Long hots - $7
- Spinach - $7: Sauces to take home
- Truffle fries - $11: Broccoli rabe
- Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite - $4: Still or sparkling water
- Italian lemon or blood orange soda - $5: Steaz peach or blueberry tea
- Kids apple juice - $3.50: Starters & salads Entrées Pasta Desserts & more
- Chicken parmigiana - $30: Slow-simmered Bell & Evans chicken breast, Italian plum tomatoes, grated pecorino, fresh basil, side of spaghetti.
- Pork chop - $36: Heritage pork, seasoned breadcrumbs, garlic white wine, broccoli rabe, long hots.
- Salmon - $37: Crab and shrimp stuffed salmon, lemon butter spinach, gold potatoes.
- Halibut - $39: Line-caught Pacific halibut, panko & pecorino oreganata, garlic potatoes, citrus butter sauce.
- Lasagna bolognese - $28: Fresh pasta, simmered beef ragu, house-made mozzarella, creamy béchamel, San Marzano tomatoes, grated pecorino.
- Corn & sausage risotto - $29: Creamy arborio rice, fresh corn purée, Italian fennel sausage, crispy pancetta, Reggiano.
- Chicken porcini - $29: Bell & Evans boneless breast, roasted cremini & porcini mushrooms, gold potato purée, sweet wine & porcini glaze.
- Chicken balsamico - $27: Roasted thighs & breast, sweet peppers & onions, parmesan polenta, aged balsamic.
- Chicken Milanese - $24: Crispy Bell & Evans chicken breast, Mediterranean salad, olives, shallots, cherry tomatoes, Reggiano, balsamic vinaigrette.
- Lemon pecorino crusted chicken - $29: Crispy Bell & Evans chicken breast crusted with lemon and pecorino, creamy lemon sauce, herb-roasted potatoes.
- Eggplant parmesan - $27: Layered eggplant, house-made mozzarella, San Marzano, pecorino, fresh basil, side of spaghetti.
- Pasta add burrata - $5: Rigatoncini vodka the favorite
- Spaghetti pomodoro - $20: Spaghetti, Neapolitan pomodorini, sautéed garlic, extra virgin olive oil, basil & pecorino Romano.
- Spaghetti carbonara - $25: Spaghetti, cage-free eggs, pancetta, pecorino, cracked black pepper.
- Tagliatelle beef rib ragu - $34: Slow-simmered beef, Italian soffritto, milk, tomato passata, pecorino.
- Tiramisu - $15: Mascarpone, eggs, espresso, amaretto, sponge cake, shaved chocolate.
- Chocolate layer cake - $15: Rich Valrhona chocolate, chocolate buttercream.
- New York cheesecake - $15
- Carrot cake - $15: Coffee & tea
- Espresso - $4.50
- Americano - $4.50
- Herbal tea - $4.50
- Latte - $5
- Cappuccino - $6
- Italian lemon or blood orange soda - $5: Steaz peach or blueberry tea
- Kids apple juice - $3.50: Prices listed reflect our in-house dining menu. Prices for online orders placed through third-party delivery platforms may vary.
- Vodka sauce - $10 pint · $20 quart
- Tiramisu - $15
- Cappuccino - $6: Private parties at Suprema
Hours
- Mon–Tue 10:30 AM–4:00 PM
- Wed–Thu 10:30 AM–9:00 PM
- Fri–Sat 10:30 AM–9:30 PM
- Sun 11:00 AM–8:00 PM