Maxie's Supper Club & Oyster Bar
- Type: Restaurant
- Location: Ithaca, New York
- Cuisine: Seafood
Maxie's Supper Club & Oyster Bar offers southern dishes, shucked shellfish & live music draw boisterous crowds at this hip spot open late in Ithaca, New York. Listing information from OpenStreetMap contributors (openstreetmap.org/copyright), used under the Open Database License.
Menu
- Grilled Shrimp Skewers (2) - $21.00: apple-ginger slaw, honey-chipotle glaze
- Cajun-Seared Mountain Trout - $38.00: smoked creole cream sauce, parmesan & chive grit cake, sauteed baby spinach with roasted garlic
- Maxie’s Mighty-Mighty Gumbo - $9.00: with andouille sausage & chicken, over rice
- Crab and Corn Chowder - $10.00
- Supper Club Salad - $12.00: local field greens, bleu cheese, toasted pecans & fresh apple, raspberry vinaigrette
- Caesar Salad - $11.00: romaine lettuce with traditional caesar dressing, parmesan cheese and garlic croutons
- Add to Your Salad: chicken breast 8 / catfish 12/ shrimp 10 / ahi tuna 12/ fried oysters 13/ portobello 7/ BBQ organic tofu 7
- NOLA BBQ SHRIMP - $14.00: spicy worcestershire-rosemary sauce, garlic bread
- Fried Green Tomatoes - $12.00: with remoulade
- Broiled Oysters (4pc): chef's daily preparation
- Cracker-Crusted Oysters - $19.00: with creamy mignonette
- Gumbo Fries - $15.00: loaded with cheddar cheese, gumbo gravy
- Crab Cake - $20.00: with cajun mayo & rwb slaw
- Peel n Eat Shrimp - $11.00: chilled, dusted with old bay seasoning
- Steamed Littleneck Clams - $26.00: in garlic butter broth with grilled french bread
- Bleu Cheese Burger - $17.00: with caramelized onions and mayo
- Fried Shrimp - $18.00: with remoulade
- Chicken - $17.00: grilled, bbq, fried or blackened, with mayo
- Fried Oysters - $20.00: with creamy mignonette
- Blackened Catfish - $19.00: with tartar sauce
- BBQ Organic Tofu - $16.00: topped with creamy slaw
- Andouille Sausage - $18.00: with remoulade, 'rwb' slaw
- Chicken Fingers - $11.95: with french fries
- Pulled Pork Sandwich - $11.50: with fries
- Kid's Fried Shrimp - $11.95: with french fries
- Kid's Fish Fry - $11.95: with fries
- BBQ Organic Tofu - $10.95: with french fries
- Grilled Cheese - $10.95: with fries
- Kid's Noodles - $9.50: with butter and cheese
- Shrimp and Grits - $21.00: shrimp, rich tasso ham gravy, over grits
- Jambalaya “Me-Oh-My-A” - $26.00: shrimp, local andouille, & chicken in zesty creole rice
- Vegan Jambalaya - $23.00: smoked tofu, pecans, spinach, & black beans in creole rice
- Maxie's Deluxe Crab Cake Platter - $38.00: with cajun mayo and rwb slaw
- Cajun-Seared Ahi Tuna - $38.00: maple brown butter, horseradish potato cake, sautéed spinach
- Chicken-Fried Chicken - $24.00: with mashed potatoes, tasso gravy and maple-braised collard greens
- Blackened Catfish - $25.00: creole sauce, black beans and rice, maple-braised collard greens
- Pulled Pork Sandwich - $21.00: Eastern NC style, topped with slaw, on a sesame roll, BBQ beans
- Pulled Pork Plate - $23.00: Eastern NC style, BBQ beans, Traditional Slaw
- Fish Fry-or-Shrimp Fry - $25.00: with tartar or cocktail sauce, rough-cut fries, creamy slaw
- Blackened Fish Tacos - $24.00: soft corn tortillas, pico de gallo, lettuce, side of black beans and rice
- Grilled Portobello - $23.00: with creole sauce, horseradish potato cake, baby spinach
- BBQ Organic Tofu - $21.00: KC-style, mashed potatoes, sautéed spinach
- Grits and Gravy - $8.50
- Maple-Braised Collard Greens - $8.00
- BBQ Beans - $6.50
- Slaw: ‘RWB’ -Or- Creamy - $6.50: None
- Vegan Black Beans & Rice - $6.50: None
- Sautéed Spinach - $7.50: None
- Mashed Potatoes - $7.50
- Spicy Cajun Fries - $7.00: with cajun mayo
- Rough-Cut Fries - $6.50
- Field Greens - $8.00: Choice of dressing
- Freshly Shucked Riptide Oysters (MA) - $3.95: on crushed ice with cocktail, fresh horseradish, mignonette and lemon wedge
- Freshly Shucked Salutation Cove Oysters (PEI) - $3.95: on crushed ice with cocktail, fresh horseradish, mignonette and lemon wedge
- Freshly Shucked Littleneck Clams - $2.25: on crushed ice with cocktail, fresh horseradish, and lemon wedge
- Peel n Eat Shrimp - $11.00: chilled, dusted with old bay seasoning
- Maxie-Rita - $12.00: Arette blanco tequila, cointreau, triple sec, sour & real lime juice.
- State Street Hurricane - $12.00: Dark & light rum, passion fruit and real lime juice.
- Cajun Bloody Mary - $11.00: Vodka, tomato juice, horseradish & cajun seasoning, garnished with shrimp.
- Oyster Shooter - $7.50: Vodka, fresh-shucked oyster & cajun bloody juice.
- Mojito! - $11.00: Light rum with muddled limes, fresh mint, sugar and soda.
- Sazerac Sazerac - $12.50: Pernod coated glass with sazerac rye, peychaud’s bitters, simple syrup, served ‘up’.
- Tipsy Gardener - $11.00: Hangar one vodka, st. germain, fresh lemons & soda.
- Skyy Citrus Cosmopolitan - $12.00: Skyy citrus vodka, cointreau, fresh limes & cranberry, served ‘up’.
- Supper Club Sidecar - $12.00: Maker’s mark bourbon, cointreau & lemonade with a sugared rim, served ‘up’.
- Maxie Mule: Vodka, whiskey, bourbon, rum or tequila, squeeze of limes, ithaca ginger beer, on the rocks.
- Maxie’s Pimm’s Cup - $10.00: Muddled cucumber with pimm’s, sour and ginger.
- Hendrick's Experience - $11.00: hendrick's gin, st. germain, muddled cucumber, soda
- Finger Lakes Old Fashioned - $12.50: McKenzie bourbon, peychaud's bitters, brown sugar, orange, on the rocks
- Caipirinha - $10.00: cachaça, lime, sugar
- Blanc de Blancs, Veuve Ambal, NV - $9.00: (Jura, FR) apricot, almond, refreshing.
- Rosé of Pinot Noir, The Pinot Project, 2024 - $10.00: (Vias, FR) raspberry, rose petals, bright acidity
- Sauvignon Blanc, Thresher, 2025 - $8.50: (Central Valley, Chile) citrus, bell pepper, fresh.
- Chardonnay Reserve, Atwater Vineyards, 2022 - $12.00: (Burdett, NY) crisp, toasty, balanced
- Malbec, Vive, 2024 - $10.00: (Mendoza, ARG) blackberries, cocoa, round tannins
- Cabernet Sauvignon, Crosby, 2022 - $9.00: (California) red currant & black plum, soft tannins, dry.
- NY Seneca Lodge Amber Ale - $5.50: 5.3% ABV
- NY Southern Tier 8 Days a Week Blonde Ale - $5.00: 4.8% ABV
- NY Lucky Hare Falcon Punch IPA - $6.00: 6.2% ABV
- NY Sloop NY Pale Ale - $6.00: 5.2% ABV
Hours
- Wed–Thu, Sun 3:30 PM–9:00 PM
- Fri–Sat 3:30 PM–9:30 PM