Mehaffies Pies
- Type: Artisan Food Producer
- Category: Bakery
- Location: Dayton, Ohio
Famous for Pies & Cheesecakes Since 1930 Listing information from OpenStreetMap contributors (openstreetmap.org/copyright), used under the Open Database License.
News and blog (10)
- Small Business Saturday: Mehaffies' Role as a Dayton Small Business: This Small Business Saturday, held on November 28, 2026, we want to celebrate what it means to be a longtime Dayton small business, the relationships we’ve…
- Why Do We Crave Spiced Flavors in the Fall?: Farewell summer – fall spice season is officially here! If you’ve found yourself suddenly dreaming of warm Dutch Apple, Pecan, or Pumpkin Pie, you’re far from…
- Tailgate Traditions: Why Pie Needs a Place on Gameday: Fall weekends across Ohio carry a distinct kind of magic and tailgating is where the real magic happens! Adding your favorite Mehaffies pie or dessert to your…
- How to Celebrate Back-to-School Season with Mehaffies: Kick off the new school year with a "Back-to-School Pie Party" right in your kitchen. Gather around the table over your favorite Mehaffies pie, New York-style…
- A History of Mehaffies Pies at 3013 Linden Avenue, Dayton, OH: At Mehaffies Pies, we know that the best things in life aren’t just about the goals we set for ourselves, but the moments we share with others. Today, we are…
- Why Cream Pies are Summer’s Best Friend!: When it’s hot outside, a heavy dessert might be the last thing on your mind. Instead, a chilling, refreshing, and perfectly sweet cream pie is the best end to…
- Memorial Day: Tips For Planning Your First BBQ of the Summer: Memorial Day gatherings signify the unofficial start to summer. Smoky grills, laughs with friends, and delicious desserts are the key elements that can’t be…
- April Showers: The Best Pies for a Rainy Day: While we wait for the full bloom of May, April in the Miami Valley usually asks us to trade our sunglasses for umbrellas. At Mehaffies Pies, since 1930, we’ve…
- St. Patrick’s Day Pairings: Finding Your Pot of Gold at Mehaffies: You don’t need to chase a rainbow to find a “pot of gold” this month. You just need to find your way to Mehaffies Pies at 3013 Linden Avenue. We believe the…
- A “Batch” Made in Heaven: Sharing Love and Connection with Pie: At Mehaffies Pies, we know that the best things in life aren’t just about the goals we set for ourselves, but the moments we share with others. Today, we are…
Menu
- Apple - $12.00
- Cherry - $15.00
- Dutch Apple - $12.00
- Peach - $12.00
- Pineapple - $12.00
- Pumpkin - $12.00
- Raisin - $12.00
- Rhubarb - $12.00
- Blackberry - $12.00
- Blueberry - $12.00
- Strawberry - $12.00: Red Raspberry
- Mixed Berry - $12.00: Strawberry Rhubarb
- Banana - $12.00
- Chocolate - $12.00: Chocolate Peanut Butter
- Coconut - $12.00: Lemon Meringue
- Peanut Butter - $12.00
- Sugar Cream - $12.00: Chocolate, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Coconut, and Peanut Butter Cream Pies are available with whipped topping for $10.50 each.
- Cherry - $12.00
- Apple - $12.00: Specialty Desserts
- Chocolate Fudge Iced Brownie - $3.00
- Haffies - $2.50: 1 Dozen Cake Pops
- Pumpkin Roll - Small - $8.00: Pumpkin Roll - Large
- Sweet Potato Pie - $15.00: Whipped Cream
- Apple Crunch - $12.00: Cherry Crunch
- Lemon Crunch - $12.00: Peach Crunch
- Blackberry Crunch - $12.00: Blueberry Crunch
- Key Lime - $12.00
- Creamsicle - $12.00: "New York Style" Cheesecake
- Cheesecake by the Slice - $3.00: Single Cheesecake on a Stick
- Cheesecake Toppings - $5.00: Strawberry 15oz
- Boston Cream Cake - $12.00
- Carrot Cake - $12.00: Double Chocolate Cake
- German Chocolate Cake - $12.00: Cake by the Slice
- Custard - $12.00: Lemon Chess*
- Pecan - $15.00: Butterscotch (whipped topping)
- Medium & Dark Roast - $15.95
Hours
- Mon–Sat 8:00 AM–6:00 PM