Pearl Valley Cheese Inc
- Type: Artisan Food Producer
- Location: Fresno, Ohio
A Swiss family tradition of superior cheesemaking for 80 years. Award-winning Swiss Cheese and Colby Cheese. In Coshocton County, Ohio near Amish Country.
Products (56)
- Mild Swiss Cheese - $6.35: Award-Winning Mild Swiss There’s a reason this is our most popular cheese! Our Mild Swiss is a two-time gold medalist at the World Championship Cheese Contest (2014 & 2024), recognized for its…
- Baby Swiss Cheese - $6.35: Classic Baby Swiss Mild, creamy, and irresistibly smooth, Baby Swiss is a beloved favorite here in Amish Country. Known for its smaller holes and softer texture compared to traditional Swiss, it…
- Aged Swiss Cheese - $6.70: Aged Like Fine Wine One of our best-selling varieties, this award-winning Aged Swiss Cheese is carefully aged in a cool environment to develop its signature bold, nutty flavor. The extended aging…
- Smoked Swiss Cheese - $6.99: A True Classic Our Smoked Swiss Cheese has a nutty, smooth, smoky flavor that is truly irresistible! Our classic Swiss is naturally smoked in a smokehouse to add a unique depth of flavor to an…
- Colby Cheese - $5.95: Classic Colby Cheese It may be classic, but it’s not boring. Our Colby is a mild, yellow cheese that is delicious for snacking, slicing, shredding, or cubing. Many people are familiar with Colby…
- Marble Cheese - $5.95: Marble Cheese (Colby Jack) Also known as Colby Jack or Cojack, this mild, creamy cheese is a perfect blend of Colby and Monterey Jack. It melts smoothly, slices easily, and adds a colorful touch to…
- Pepper Jack Cheese - $5.95: Spicy Monterey Jack Packed with a zesty blend of diced red and green jalapeños and habanero peppers, this Monterey Jack cheese delivers a bold, fiery kick. Perfect for those who crave heat, it adds…
- Farmers Cheese - $5.95: Mild and Creamy With its mild, comforting flavor—often described as a perfect balance between mozzarella and Colby—Farmer’s Cheese is a deliciously wholesome choice. It boasts lower sodium and fat…
- Super Hot Jumping Jack Cheese - $6.35: Spice Up your Life Designed for the true spicy food lover, this marbled cheese packs a bold punch with a fiery blend of habaneros, jalapeños, and ghost peppers. Its vibrant marbled appearance makes…
- Lacey Baby Swiss Cheese - $6.35: A Creamy Classic Experience the smooth, creamy texture with a subtle Swiss flavor that’s perfect for slicing onto your cheese plate or layering in a sandwich. Its mild, approachable taste makes it a…
- Lacey Style Cheese - $6.35: Reduced- Sodium Swiss Cheese Enjoy the classic, mild flavor of our semi-soft Swiss cheese—now with part-skim goodness and reduced sodium for a healthier choice. Perfect for cheese lovers who want…
- Bacon Cheese - $5.95: Bacon Lovers Bliss This creamy American-style processed cheese is packed with real bacon bits, delivering a savory, smoky flavor and a satisfying texture in every bite. Soft and versatile, it’s…
- Horseradish Cheese - $5.95: Bold Horseradish Cheese We’ve taken our creamy white American-style processed cheese and amped it up with plenty of bold, natural horseradish. The result? A flavorful kick that horseradish fans will…
- Jalapeno Cheese (Hot Pepper) - $5.95: Bold with a Kick This creamy, American-style processed cheese is kicked up a notch with real jalapeño peppers for a bold, spicy flavor. It’s a favorite among heat lovers and melts beautifully…
- Onion Cheese - $5.95: Bold Onion, Smooth Cheese This smooth, American-style cheese is infused with the fresh, savory flavor of green onion. It’s perfect for layering on sandwiches, adding a flavorful twist to your…
- Pepperoni Cheese - $5.95: Pepperoni Perfection This creamy, American-style processed cheese is loaded with real pepperoni pieces in every bite. Bold, savory, and irresistibly flavorful, it’s one of our most popular varieties…
- Garlic Cheese - $5.95: Savory Garlic Cheese This American-style processed cheese is infused with bold garlic flavor for a delicious twist on a classic. Smooth, creamy, and perfectly melty, it’s an ideal choice for cheese…
- Extra Sharp White Cheddar Cheese - $11.30: Aged to Perfection Aged for over 3 years, this natural Extra Sharp White Cheddar is crafted for those who crave bold, complex flavor. With its nutty notes and crisp, tangy bite, it delivers a…
- Sharp Colored Cheddar Cheese - $7.20: A True Classic Our Cheddar Cheese is everything you love about a timeless favorite — aged a bit longer than our Mild Cheddar for a richer, sharper flavor. Its vibrant orange hue? 100% natural.…
- Havarti Cheese - $7.75: You won’t believe it’s cheese—not butter! Known as “Butter Cheese,” Havarti is delightfully soft, creamy, and melts with ease. Whether sliced, cubed, or grilled, its smooth texture makes it…
- Mozzarella Cheese - $5.95: A Family Favorite Versatile and flavorful, our Mozzarella is perfect cubed for snacking or easily shredded at home to melt beautifully on your favorite pizza. Creamy, mild, and consistently…
- Muenster Cheese - $5.95: Mild & Creamy Muenster You can’t go wrong with this classic favorite! Our mild, creamy brick-style cheese is dipped in natural annatto for that signature Muenster look and flavor. Perfectly…
- Vegetable Yogurt Cheese - $7.20: Heini’s Vegetable Yogurt Cheese Discover the perfect blend of creamy yogurt cheese enriched with vibrant bits of fresh vegetables and aromatic spices. A local favorite, handcrafted by Heini’s Cheese…
- Provolone Cheese - $5.95: Crowd-Pleaser Provolone A classic Italian favorite, our Provolone is perfect for your next pizza, pasta, or cheese platter. Whether you shred it, slice it, or cube it, its smooth, mild flavor and…
- Chipotle Pepper Jack - $5.95: S mokey Chipotle Peppe r Jack A bold twist on our classic Jack cheese—infused with smoked chipotle peppers for a rich, smoky heat that builds with every bite. Creamy, spicy, and full of flavor, it’s…
- Ohio Pure Maple Syrup - $15: This all-natural maple syrup is produced by Herring Farms in Harpster, Ohio. The practice of tapping maple trees in the spring is a tradition that has been passed down through many generations of…
- Gouda Cheese - $6.35: Golden Hue Gouda Our all-natural Gouda is crafted with unique cultures that create a rich, creamy, and buttery flavor. This mild cheese is aged for approximately 30 days, giving it a golden hue and…
- American Sliced Cheese - $5.95: Pre-Sliced American Cheese Smooth, creamy, and ready to serve—this classic American cheese is a go-to favorite for grilled cheese sandwiches, burgers, and everyday snacking. Conveniently pre-sliced…
- We Love Cheese Short sleeve t-shirt - $28.50: The tri-blend fabric creates a vintage, fitted look. And extreme durability makes this t-shirt withstand repeated washings and still remain super comfortable. • Tri-blend construction (50%…
- Child Onesie Shirt Undeniably Dairy - $25: Dress your baby to the nines with this 100% cotton one piece. It has three snap leg closure for easy changing, a comfortable envelope neckline, and a beautiful print that's bound to get the baby all…
- Summer Sausage 12oz - $8.19: All-Beef Summer Sausage – Original Flavor, 12 oz Crafted from 100% high-quality beef, this Original Flavor Summer Sausage delivers rich, savory taste in every slice. With its classic seasoning and…
- Jalapeno and Cheese Summer Sausage 12 oz - $8.19: Winesburg Meats Summer Sausage with Jalapeño & Cheese – 12 oz Bold, smoky, and packed with flavor—this 12 oz summer sausage combines premium meats, spicy jalapeños, and creamy cheese in every bite.…
- Smoked Horseradish Cheese - $6.99: Smokey Horseradish Cheese A pasteurized processed horseradish cheese infused with bold, smoky flavor. It melts perfectly on a burger and makes a flavorful snack on its own. A one-of-a-kind cheese…
- Smoked Hot Pepper Cheese - $6.99: Smoky Hot Pepper Cheese A pasteurized processed hot pepper cheese with bold, smoky flavor. It melts beautifully—perfect for cheese dips, mac and cheese, or simply enjoying as a spicy snack. Packed…
- Colby Swiss Swirl Cheese - $6.35: Colby Meets Swiss Our marbled cheese combines the best of our Colby and Swiss-style traditions into one delicious creation. Whether served on a cheese plate or added to a sandwich, it’s full of…
- Smoked Gouda Cheese - $6.99: Signature Smoked Gouda Our signature Gouda cheese—now with a rich, smoky twist! This flavorful, all-natural addition is sure to be a hit on any cheese board or party tray. This all-natural cheese is…
- Salsa Jack Cheese - $6.35: Spice It Up! This tasty cheese is a Colby-based, orange-colored blend seasoned with bold salsa flavors—featuring hints of cumin, garlic, and a touch of peppery heat. It’s delicious on a cheese board…
- Pearl Valley Cheese Trucker Cap - $25: This six-panel trucker cap with a mesh back will be a comfy and classic choice for a perfect day in the sun. • 60% cotton, 40% polyester • Mid-profile cap with a low-profile embroidery area •…
- Pearl Valley Unisex Hoodie - $32.34: Everyone needs a cozy go-to hoodie to curl up in, so go for one that's soft, smooth, and stylish. It's the perfect choice for cooler evenings! • 50% pre-shrunk cotton, 50% polyester • Fabric weight…
- Smoked Cheddar Cheese - $6.99: Smokey Cheddar Delight A rich, colored pasteurized process cheddar cheese packed with bold, smoky flavor that delights the palate. Smooth and creamy in texture, it’s the perfect snack to enjoy on…