Butterfingers
- Type: Artisan Food Producer
- Category: Bakery
- Location: Highland, Indiana
Who we are At Butterfingers, we believe in being more than just a delicatessen & dessert shop. We believe in bringing joy to the community with our creations. We have been serving the Highland and Munster area for over 30 years and are dedicated to quality and ensuring our patrons enjoy every dish & dessert…
News and blog (1)
- Page Closed for maintenance: Sorry for the inconvenience! We're doing site maintenance and will be up and running soon! Thank you for understanding and in the meantime, feel free to check…
Menu
- inch – 48 pieces // - $47
- inch – 96 pieces // - $ 89: Cookie Trays
- inch – 3 dozen // - $35
- inch – 6 dozen // - $65: Cookie & Brownie Trays
- Individual Berries // - $1.75
- inch tray – approx. 30 berries // - $55
- inch – serves approx. 20 people // - $48: Veggie Trays w/ Dip
- inch – 12 mini sandwiches // - $57
- inch – 20 mini sandwiches // - $95: *All sandwich trays made with your choice of sandwiches
- Spinach or Cheese Ravioli // - $9.75: Pork Tenderloin w/ Apricot Mustard // $12.50 per lb
- Carrot * // - $36
- Apple Bavarian // - $38
- German Chocolate * // - $38
- Double Chocolate Mousse // - $40
- Sour Cream Fudge // - $36
- Strawberry Cream // - $36
- Lemon Raspberry // - $36
- Raspberry Pound Cake // - $29
- Amaretto Pound Cake // - $29
- Raspberry Fudge // - $46
- Banana // - $34
- Hazelnut Buttercream * // - $40
- Red Velvet // - $33
- Coconut Layer Cake // - $36
- White Chocolate/Raspberry // - $36
- Cinnamon Almond Coffee * // - $30
- Lemon Blueberry Pound Cake // - $29
- Vanilla Layer Cake // - $33
- Sour Cream Cheesecake // - $40
- Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake // - $40
- Marble Cheesecake // - $40
- Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake // - $40
- Brownies & Bars // - $3.50: Fudge Walnut*, Double Fudge, Cream Cheese*, Soufflé, Peanut Butter*, Cherry Cream Cheese bars, Lemon Cream Cheese Bars, Strawberry Cream…
- large // - $4.50 | mini // $3.50: Banana, Coconut, Cherry, Chocolate Cream- Filled, Oreo, Vanilla, Lemond, Red Velvet, Caramel, Strawberry, Reese’s*, Confetti, Vanilla or…
- Apple, Peach, Key Lime // - $24
- Blueberry, Cherry // - $26: Celebration Cakes
- All cakes are 10 inches // - $60: Carrot Cake*, Banana, Red Velvet, Vanilla Layer Cake
- Butterfingers Sheet Cake // - $65: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Carrot*, Banana cake, with choice of Cream Cheese, Whipped Cream, Chocolate Buttercream or Raspberry Cream…
- Butter Croissants : mini // $.89 | large // - $1.29
- Bread Loaves // - $3.95: Cracked Wheat, White, Vegetable, Sour Dough
- Filled Croissants // - $3.25: Almond*, Chocolate, Maple Pecan*, Cream Cheese, Strawberry Cream Cheese, Blueberry Cream Cheese
- half // - $4.75 | full // $7: Croissant, Bread, Pretzel Bun, or Wrap: Tomato Basil, Flour or Honey Wheat
- small // - $6.50 | large // $9.50: Meat, Cheese & Toppings can be chosen from the Sandwich menu above
- Box Lunch // - $14: Large Sandwich, choice of meatless salad, 2 cookies or 1 brownie
- Bag Lunch // - $10.25: Large Sandwich or Wrap, choice of meatless salad, & chips
- slice // - $4.50 | whole // $19.50: Ham & Swiss, Lorraine, Broccoli & Cheddar, Spinach & Feta, Bacon, Ham & Cheddar, Veggie, Broccoli Red Pepper