Sweet Pea's
- Type: Artisan Food Producer
- Category: Bakery
- Location: Elk River, Minnesota
Award-winning scratch-made pies in Mayville, WI — worth the drive from Milwaukee or Madison. Small-batch family recipes with vegan, gluten-free & sugar-free options. Visit our charming historic Main Street shop or order online for shipping. Corporate Gifts, Fundraisers, Custom Orders and large events welcome.
Products (60)
- Cake Type - 6 - $6: Listed at $6.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Frosting Variety - 6 - $2: Listed at $2.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Cake Variety - 6 - $2: Listed at $2.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Cake Type - 8 - $8: Listed at $8.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Frosting Variety - 8 - $2: Listed at $2.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Cake Variety - 8 - $2: Listed at $2.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Caramel Cashew Bar - $6.95: Listed at $6.95 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Ice Cream Sandwich - $4.85: Listed at $4.85 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Cake Variety - Sheet Cake 1/2 - $3: Listed at $3.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Frosting Variety - Sheet Cake 1/2 - $5: Listed at $5.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Pup Cup - $1: Listed at $1.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Ice Cream Pie 9" - $25: Graham cracker crust is filled with pie then topped with whipped icing and garnished with flavor-appropriate sauces and candies. Serves 8 - 12. Listed at $25.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Pet Pop - $2.50: Listed at $2.50 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Buttercream Frosting, 1 pound - $4: Listed at $4.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Honey Custard Pie - $24: Our flaky vegan pastry crust gets filled with a smooth and creamy custard filling made with local honey, brown sugar, and greek yogurt. Some people say it's their favorite pie, others that it…
- Cake Size - $26: Listed at $26.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Decoration Preference- 6 Traditional - $5: Listed at $5.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Lemon Swiss Meringue Pie - $24: Aunt Nona's Lemon Bar recipe is baked in a graham cracker crust and then topped with torched swiss meringue frosting. We don't think you will find this pie anywhere else but right here at Sweet…
- Berry Custard Pie - $20: Creamy custard bursts with raspberries, blackberries, and blueberries in a perfect summer combination. The standard order is frozen, ready-to-bake. Pickup in Mayville WI only. Options…
- Lemon Ice Box Pie - $22: Based on a nostalgic recipe, this tangy, fluffy lemon pie is made in a graham cracker crust and topped with sugared lemon zest. Pickup in Mayville WI only. Options: original and gluten-free-friendly…
- Peaches and Cream Pie - $18: Sweet summer peaches and heavy cream combine with cinnamon for a peaches and ice cream vibe. Listed at $18.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Rhubarb Custard Pie - $20: Creamy custard is the perfect counterpart to tart rhubarb. Pickup in Mayville WI only. Listed at $20.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Dubai Chocolate Strawberries Cup - $14.22: Fresh strawberries are covered with chocolate sauce and pistachio kunafa butter then topped with a toasted blend of pistachio and kunafa Listed at $14.22 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Pet Cake - $3.95: Listed at $3.95 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Pie Making Session (3 guests) - $150: Listed at $150.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Ice Cream Shop Passport - $25.95: 25-26 Edition. Limited Supply. Explore 110+ Wisconsin ice cream shops and growing. Enjoy 50% off two ice cream creations at each stop, (with occasional deal exceptions or fun tweaks,) valid through…
- Egg, Hashbrown & Cheese 9x13 - $38: Listed at $38.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Blueberry Puff 9x13 - $27: Listed at $27.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Caramel French Toast 9x13 - $25: Listed at $25.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Malt - $6.95: Listed at $6.95 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Vegan Crust Bottom (2) - $5.99: Listed at $5.99 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Shake - $6.45: Listed at $6.45 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Vegan Crust top/bottom (2 pk of ea) - $9.99: Listed at $9.99 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Cookie/Bar - $2: Listed at $2.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Cake, Individual - $2.75: Listed at $2.75 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Strawberry Chantilly Cake - $36: Light and airy white cake, Strawberry Chantilly Cream Filling, Vanilla Chantilly frosting Listed at $36.00 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Peanut Butter Bar - $5.95: Our peanut butter bar will delight peanut butter cup lovers. The peanut butter center is covered with a peanut butter chocolate blend. While recipe testing, we had to hide the extras! Listed at…
- ACAI BOWL VARIATIONS - $9.45: Please choose the product ACAI BOWLS to make your selections. Listed at $9.45 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Ice Cream Cake 8" - $38.50: Create a unique ice cream cake featuring super-premium Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream (Madison, WI), vanilla/chocolate cake, and fluffy whipped icing. Order today! Listed at $38.50 on sweetpeaspies.com.
- Smoothie Bowls - $9.45: Discover the difference homemade makes ! This Acai Smoothie Bowl features a base of organic Acai , blended thick and creamy like soft-serve ice cream. The star is the freshly baked, homemade granola…
News and blog (10)
- The Best Ice Cream & Desserts in Dodge County, Wisconsin — and Why Sweet Pea's Might Just Ruin You for Everywhere Else: Wisconsin takes its desserts seriously. Always has. Whether it's a Friday night fish fry ending with a slice of pie, a summer road trip detour for a legendary…
- Custom Cakes, Cheesecakes & More – Order Online from Sweet Pea's Wisconsin Kitchen: Most people know me as a pie maker. And yes, pies are my heart. But if you've ever wondered whether Sweet Pea's has more up its sleeve — the answer is a warm…
- Things to Do in Dodge County, WI | Mayville Weekend Getaway Guide: Things to Do in Dodge County, WI — Your Mayville Weekend Getaway Guide Nestled in the heart of Dodge County, Wisconsin, Mayville is a hidden gem that punches…
- Corporate Housing & Furnished Executive Apartments in Mayville, Wisconsin: Mayville, WI Furnished Housing for Travel Nurses & Corporate Stays If you are looking for corporate housing or travel nurse accommodations near Dodge County…
- Why Our Dodge County Pie Shop is Your New Smoothie Bowl Destination: Why Our Dodge County Pie Shop is Your New Smoothie Bowl Destination You probably know us for our signature flaky crusts and the best ice cream near me, but at…
- Calculating the True Cost of Baking a Pie (and Why Your Local Bake Shop’s Prices Might Actually Save You Money): What you *actually* pay for when you buy a small-batch pie At first glance, a pie might look like “just fruit and flour.” But at Sweet Pea’s, we know and we…
- Why the Type of Flour You Use Matters in Baking — Especially in Pie Crust: When it comes to baking the perfect pie crust, most people think of butter vs. shortening or how cold your dough should be. But there's another ingredient…
- Discover Why Sweet Pea’s Pies Tops the List of Best Pie Shops Near Me: There is something about the scent of a freshly baked pie that brings warmth to the soul. Maybe it is the buttery crust, the sweet aroma of seasonal fruits…
- How to Run a Pie Fundraiser That Sells — A Step-by-Step Guide for Schools, Clubs, & Teams: Pie fundraisers are popular for good reason - pies are nostalgic, delicious, and make the whole house smell irresistible. But not every pie sale is…
- Five Top Fundraiser Ideas for Schools in Wisconsin: What Works Best (and Why Pies Lead the Way): Raising money for school programs, sports teams, or club activities in Wisconsin isn’t always easy. Between cold weather, busy schedules, and stiff…